How the frick did a fricking FAN FILM manage to do a better Obi-Wan vs Darth Vader fight than a multi-billion dollar company like Disney?
The fight scene in episode 3 of the Obi-Wan show was complete garbage. Garbage soundtrack, garbage choreography, no weight to the encounter at all.
Fan film
Obi-Wan show
>How the frick did a fricking FAN FILM manage to do a better Obi-Wan vs Darth Vader fight than a multi-billion dollar company like Disney?
because the shit you're shilling is a reimagining of an already existing scene, autist
the sword play in the fan edit is 10x better than the show are you fricking kidding me
It's fricking embarrassing you moron. Something an edgy 13-year-old would think is so sick and tell all his dipshit friends about.
This. Lacks soul. This was just kewl splosions and lightsaber swinging.
How much they paid you to type that?
The fan edit is 10/10, because it was made by someone who cared, not by a low IQ hire that they got for his wokism
Because the Obi-wan show is propaganda. Not designed to be entertaining or good.
That was fricking shit as well and failed to get why both Obi Wan and Vader were using classical fencing rather than this overreactive choreography for ADD teenagers.
SW ended in 1983
>classical fencing
Oh yeah, like this classical fencing maneuver
This is how Kenobi looks. A crappy fan film.
Because Obi Won hasn’t dueled anyone in 10 years and doesn’t have the same skill he had Episode 3 and Darth Vader is half machine. He can’t fight like he used too when he was Anakin. Both are nerfed due to age, disability, and loss of practice.
>Obi-Wan in rebels is confident and manages to easily kill Darth Maul
>Obi-Wan in ANH is confident and easily cuts off thugs hand at the cantina
>Obi-Wan in ANH confidently confronts vader and even has smug face before he throws the fight to Vader
>Obi-Wan in Obi-Wan show is cucked hard and has a perpetual scared look on his face and never uses his lightsaber.
They cucked him hard in his own fricking show
Because Kenobi in his own show is still upset and traumatized after Revenge of the Sith, obviously by the end of the show he'll believe again, probably after a pep talk from Quigon (disney wars loves its final episode cameos)
he was confident in ROTS too shill
Leia will give him a pep talk. they play victorious music
søys at home cheer
Obi Wan says some cringe shit like you're wise like your mother, Leia says I know. he kicks Vader's ass
He didn't look very traumatized. From the clip I saw of their fight it looks like the show is doing the thing again of making Darth Vader something Obi Wan fears because of his reputation to the fans and not Obi Wan himself. That Obi Wan would shit his pants and be helpless before Anakin is something the show created, he's not like that at the end of the Revenge of the Sith or in A New Hope.
Disney Star Wars doesn't care about characters from the originals. Obi Wan is in Kenobi to elevate Leia. he's a sad bumbling idiot to enhance kid Leia's awesomeness.
>That Obi Wan would shit his pants and be helpless before Anakin is something the show created
This. I don't mind him suffering mentally seeing Anakin in that state or just in general during the show but he should still have kept up his training and hold his own when shit goes down.
I'm glad they ignored that aspect of the prequels. Those movies were terrible.
Obi Wan wasn't traumatized or disillusioned at the end of Episode III. He looks on at Luke knowing what must be done, sacrificing his freedom and the current fight to secure a better future later on. How could he properly train Luke in the force if 1. he doesn't even believe in himself anymore 2. barely remembers how to use the force, and what he does remember is weak and 3. is full of dread and lack of hope.
the morons arguing with you haven’t watched the show or are genuine morons who don’t understand delayed gratification and just want capeshit cgi fights. btw, this is coming from someone who hates disney star wars to the point where I even think mando is shit. but in this obi is clearly going through a recapturing his mojo arc and they wanted to show how powerful vader was by having the weakened obi job. it was effective at showing the threat that vader is and it was satisfying to see him toy with a terrified obi wan. it’s the only thing so far I would call good in this series, even if the fact vader let him go was moronic. if you seriously wanted a prequel level fight for 10 minutes out of nowhere in their first confrontation you are legit stupid
Obiwan hasn’t trained since the exile.
But Yoda told him to. Retcon is obvious.
Why not? How does he expect to train Luke if he doesn't keep up on his own studies?
The idea being that someone would definitely see him levitating stuff and saber fighting so he has to hide all signs of being a jedi or he risks bringing the empire down on him and luke
He lives in the middle of the fricking desert
He lives near town and goes to work all the time. Plus there's all sorts of wanderers out there all the time.
Ben's hut was about 100 miles away from Luke's house, which was the closest house to him and even further away from any cities where the empire would be (Imperial presence on Tatooine was already minimal since it's an outer rim planet with no resources). In the EU, his house is full of Jedi artifacts, books, etc. Luke built his lightsaber in RoTJ from the stuff left there. What you're saying/what disney came up with is bullshit and contrary to the first movie.
He works in town moron. It's already been explained.
Holy frick where to even start
> that editing
> that choreography
> vader putting out the fire with the force then forgetting he can do that a second later
> not force pulling obiwan through the flames
>obi wan needing to be saved by a stronk wamen
Frick Disney
I hate everything about this
ez
the fan film guys love it
the mouse hires are just there for a check
The Vader stuff is more kino than anything else Disney has produced.
Vader in rogue one was way better
Yes but he sounded like an old geezer.
The show is trying to mix the OT and PT styles of lightsaber fights. It would be moronic if they were doing spins and flips and shit.
This. The prequel flipping was awful.
WHOEVER defends the recent duel of vader and ben is EXACTLY the problem with Hollywood now, you are very low level to please and have shit taste. You should be permabanned from posting in any movie if you say that ''fight'' was good.
the showrunners don't give a frick about what the IP is or the characters that inhabit that universe.
that probably aren't all that familiar with the IP.
they use the IP as a vehicle to tell their stories and that's all. they demolish established fan favorite character to elevate their characters.
Luke was demolished to elevate Rey
Obi Wan is being demolished to elevate Leia, who isn't OT Leia but sequels flying through space Leia.
you know they're going to spin this flotsam off into a Leia tween series.
It actually didn't do it better.
The CGI is shit, and lots of the shots are disjointed fuzzy trash.
Both attempts are cringe
This is fricking terrible
>lens flares
opinion disregarded
Modern day filming is full of hacks
Though the choreography in the original is stiff and could be improved on, it's slow for a reason. This ejects all the cinematic inspiration Lucas got from samurai films and holds little identity of its own. There's no consistency in the shot choices; the shaky cam especially doesn't sit right.
Watch this to understand what Lucas was going for.
Kind of weird that Lucas forgot his own inspirations when he made the prequels
lucas got up his ass with religion and philosophical elements and his stupid wills shit and forgot about good filmmaking.
Star Wars is nothing but Greek mythology and western philosophy (with a lot of Nietzsche thrown in). Without those elements, you get Solo, a very mediocre and generic Sci-Fi movie.
>denouement of the entire OT is evil being defeated with the power of forgiveness
>nietzschean
kind of the complete opposite
it always had the religious elements in and they’re basically the only reason star wars is memorable or different from other sci fi shit. extremely weird reddity complaint
The most egregious thing about Obi-Wan is how visually muddled and bland it is, like some kids just shot it in a strip mall parking lot in the middle of the night with a camcorder
>Oh no! my student I left for dead has come back for revenge!
>Better walk aimlessly around a rock quarry.
>there are third world pajeets on here who think that tasteless moronic fanmade one is good
>t. mouse shill
it’s synder tier dude. not defending the disney garbage but holy frick that fan made one is ugly, brainless garbage
Cause they're not trying to purposefully destroy star wars like cathlene kennedu.
That fight was stupid as frick too for different reasons. It's sad that a fight as poorly choreographed as the original still can't be topped. Probably because the story was more important that banging two CGI sticks around.
spastic reddit cosplay tier fanfic, disneys shit is garbage but at least it doesnt feel like some aspergers fever dream.