Revenge of the Sith is shit. It's the most contrived and tone deaf of the prequels, and that's saying something. RLM mocked the battle droids for being useless, but the Jedi being useless is 100x worse. They are so underpowered and pointless. Zero soul.
Yes. That's when he started getting more concerned with selling toys. I wonder what people would think of it if it didn't have that last half hour or whatever.
>Is it the weakest of a set of three movies
Yes, but it's still stronger than 1-3 or 7-9
It was directed by a guy who mostly only done TV, he's arguably the worst director of the original trilogy, with the first being directed by Lucas (not well, but the editor won an Oscar for creating something perfect from it), and the second from Lucas's old teacher. The third director they just got because he was cheap, he wasn't even their first choice.
>7 > 8 > 3
You're on drugs. 7 drops multiple slots for killing an OG character for zero reason.
>You're on drugs. 7 drops multiple slots for killing an OG character for zero reason. >NOOOOOOOOOO YOU CAN'T TAKE MY FAVORITE TOY AWAY NOOOOOOOOOO THE OG CAST SHOULD BE UNTOUCHABLE BECAUSE IT HURTS MY FEEFEES THAT THEY DIED NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
>The third director they just got because he was cheap, he wasn't even their first choice.
Not true. They got him because he wasn't a member of the Director's Guild, which Lucas had an open feud with and resigned his membership.They couldn't get a Guild Director, due to Union rules.
it's been my favourite ever since I was a kid >duel with Vader >duel with the Emperor >Jabba's Palace >desert fight >space war intercut with endor war >prime Luke >yoda's death >beautiful soundtrack
there were some childish scenes, but the best bits of the whole saga were here
I basically consider ESB+ROJ as one two-part movie. ESB+ROJ is almost as good as the original Star Wars movie. But ROJ trying to stand on its own is definitely the weakest of the three movies. ROJ's biggest problem is that it feels like situations which are supposed to be dire get resolved too easily. The movie would have been better if a main character from the good guy gang died or something.
during star wars and empire Lucas has enough people to tell him no that he didn't go off the rails. by jedi he was full toy selling mode and that contributed to the parts that people don't like because jedi has some really good stuff. The prequels are what happened when lucas was surrounded by yesmen
I once read that an early version of the script had the 2nd death star being built by wookie slaves instead of over Endor. Now THOSE are furry creatures I believe could defeat stormtroopers in a slave uprising. If they'd have done that story I legit think it would be 2nd best star wars movie. Everything else was great, loved Jabba, loved Palpatine, more original Yoda, comfy Harrison Ford, comfy Lando, loved slave Leia. Women in the slave outfit is still a big fetish for me.
Not really, it was pretty kino. The last lightsaber duel was one of the best scenes in all of star wars. The weakest was episode 4 but really it wasn't even that bad, just kind of cheesy
I just realized that Ewoks are essentially first generation Minions. Same concept really, small annoying “cute” things thrown into a popular film to sell toys and attract children and soft people
It is, but it's like comparing SMB1, 2 and 3. They are all so close to a 10/10 you're splitting wiener hairs.
It has by far the best space battle scenes of any movie. It has an awesome intro with Jabba the hut and Slave Leia that stands alone like an amazing short movie by itself. The Ewoks never bothered me, but the speeder scenes and infiltration with Han being Han makes up for any shortcomings. The emotional impact of the final scene where Vader redeems himself could almost make you cry. So damn well done.
Frick the prequels.
Frick the equals.
Star Wars movies ended with this movie.
i mean yeah but its still leagues above and of the unmitigated disasters that followed
>above and of the
*above all of the
its 3am
Nice youtube name drop bro.
what
Revenge of the Sith is the best Star Wars film
Revenge of the Sith is shit. It's the most contrived and tone deaf of the prequels, and that's saying something. RLM mocked the battle droids for being useless, but the Jedi being useless is 100x worse. They are so underpowered and pointless. Zero soul.
Yes. That's when he started getting more concerned with selling toys. I wonder what people would think of it if it didn't have that last half hour or whatever.
Don't know, I never watched Soi Wars because.
5>4>7>8>3>9>6>1>2knaa28
>Is it the weakest of a set of three movies
Yes, but it's still stronger than 1-3 or 7-9
It was directed by a guy who mostly only done TV, he's arguably the worst director of the original trilogy, with the first being directed by Lucas (not well, but the editor won an Oscar for creating something perfect from it), and the second from Lucas's old teacher. The third director they just got because he was cheap, he wasn't even their first choice.
>7 > 8 > 3
You're on drugs. 7 drops multiple slots for killing an OG character for zero reason.
Lucas directed a lot of RotJ too. He might as well been credited as co director.
>You're on drugs. 7 drops multiple slots for killing an OG character for zero reason.
>NOOOOOOOOOO YOU CAN'T TAKE MY FAVORITE TOY AWAY NOOOOOOOOOO THE OG CAST SHOULD BE UNTOUCHABLE BECAUSE IT HURTS MY FEEFEES THAT THEY DIED NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
>The third director they just got because he was cheap, he wasn't even their first choice.
Not true. They got him because he wasn't a member of the Director's Guild, which Lucas had an open feud with and resigned his membership.They couldn't get a Guild Director, due to Union rules.
4>5>>6>>>3>2>1 No other movie exist in this series.
Nah seeing Luke being a Full Jedi was Kino
Everything about the throne room confrontation and duel is exquisite. I can forget the rest of the movie entirely.
Gave us the greatest coom kino for decades so it's based
it's been my favourite ever since I was a kid
>duel with Vader
>duel with the Emperor
>Jabba's Palace
>desert fight
>space war intercut with endor war
>prime Luke
>yoda's death
>beautiful soundtrack
there were some childish scenes, but the best bits of the whole saga were here
+literally perfect ending
+speeder bikes
+jabba palace
+emperor dialogue is fricking kino
-ewoks are gay
-3cpo has a red arm now?
-no alec guinness
3po has a red arm in Episode 7, not Jedi.
Alec Guinness has a cameo on Dagobagh.
Did you even watch the movie?
I basically consider ESB+ROJ as one two-part movie. ESB+ROJ is almost as good as the original Star Wars movie. But ROJ trying to stand on its own is definitely the weakest of the three movies. ROJ's biggest problem is that it feels like situations which are supposed to be dire get resolved too easily. The movie would have been better if a main character from the good guy gang died or something.
Maybe. It probably has the lowest lows, but also the highest highs in the throne room.
ROTJ is when star wars became about selling toys.
It’s the weaker overall but
>Luke faces Emperor (and Vader) in throne room
Is top Star Wars
ROTJ is like 20-30 minutes of a great movie with 90 minutes of a total dogshit one.
during star wars and empire Lucas has enough people to tell him no that he didn't go off the rails. by jedi he was full toy selling mode and that contributed to the parts that people don't like because jedi has some really good stuff. The prequels are what happened when lucas was surrounded by yesmen
This guy gets it!100% correct and accurate. I hope Rick McCallum burns in hell.
I once read that an early version of the script had the 2nd death star being built by wookie slaves instead of over Endor. Now THOSE are furry creatures I believe could defeat stormtroopers in a slave uprising. If they'd have done that story I legit think it would be 2nd best star wars movie. Everything else was great, loved Jabba, loved Palpatine, more original Yoda, comfy Harrison Ford, comfy Lando, loved slave Leia. Women in the slave outfit is still a big fetish for me.
It's my second favorite of all of Star Wars, if it wasn't for the Ewoks this movie would be remembered much more fondly
ROTJ is 2 hours of pure joy
Not really, it was pretty kino. The last lightsaber duel was one of the best scenes in all of star wars. The weakest was episode 4 but really it wasn't even that bad, just kind of cheesy
Imagine caring about a series literally intended for small children.
You are dumb as hell if you think the original Star Wars was made for children
I just realized that Ewoks are essentially first generation Minions. Same concept really, small annoying “cute” things thrown into a popular film to sell toys and attract children and soft people
It is, but it's like comparing SMB1, 2 and 3. They are all so close to a 10/10 you're splitting wiener hairs.
It has by far the best space battle scenes of any movie. It has an awesome intro with Jabba the hut and Slave Leia that stands alone like an amazing short movie by itself. The Ewoks never bothered me, but the speeder scenes and infiltration with Han being Han makes up for any shortcomings. The emotional impact of the final scene where Vader redeems himself could almost make you cry. So damn well done.
Frick the prequels.
Frick the equals.
Star Wars movies ended with this movie.