People shit on this show so much, but I honestly can't tell the difference between the writing in this show and the writing in something like Netflix's She-Ra or some episodes of Steven Universe. But those shows don't have an entire community unanimously agreeing they're shit. So why can't HGS get away with the same shit writing and visuals you would see in another other generic fantasy cartoon?
Because it released on crunchyroll and not netflix. White women do not watch crunchyroll
>I honestly can't tell the difference
Because you're retarded.
>sucking the troondick of she-ra and steven universe
NGMI
I don't know OP.
I don't watch fag shit all day like you.
>like Netflix's She-Ra or some episodes of Steven Universe. But those shows don't have an entire community unanimously agreeing they're shit
lmao anon what
All content made about HGS is shitting on it for its animation errors, awkward dialogue, bad voice acting, bad character designs, etc. She-Ra or Steven Universe might have some haters, rant blogs, or hours-long video essays describing why it's bad, but there is also a gigantic portion of people who LOVE it despite all its flaws.
There's no denying that shows like Steven Universe still have a large fanbase that think it's one of the 2010's best cartoons ever.
This show is a parody of those shows that is a product of an ai givin the entire data of tumblr as a database. With the most generic one-note characters in existence. With design that looks like a deviantart cartoon oc. All of this while it ws still being marketed as an ANIME. It shows that it was made with an entire female writer's room.
People shit on this show so much, but I honestly can't tell the difference between the writing in this show and the writing in something like Five Nights at Freddies or some episodes of Skibidi Toilet. But those shows don't have an entire community unanimously agreeing they're shit. So why can't TADC get away with the same shit writing and visuals you would see in another other generic analog horror clickbait spoop fauxlore shit?
>implying Netflix's She-Ra and Steven Universe don't have shit writing
It's the opposite. I'm almost flat-out saying I think those shows have bad writing.
Alright, fair enough. Frankly then, the only real difference beyond an absolutely bottom tier budget between this show and the other two is that Crunchyroll spectacularly missed the mark on their intended audience for this show whereas Netflix and Cartoon Network didn't. That's why the other two have a defense squad and High Guardian Spice doesn't. Crunchyroll fucked them over that hard.
Those shows had thier moments and could appeal to some people. This show is for NO ONE.
I just like the porn
It was written by groomers
It's like someone showed rwby to the most out of touch cal arts rejects on the planet. The kind that got expelled off campus because they were too shit at everything
It's like, it has all of the pieces of a good show but does nothing with it and in fact sometimes outright ignores the strengths it manages to have.
They have the archetypes and plot beats, but they just stopped there.
>Little Witch Academia with no soul that was made because they tried and failed to get the rights to Little Witch Academia
>Using money to make knock-off American """Anime""" Cartoon instead of making better Anime dubs which is what people are paying for
This is why you never pay for dubs, and you always use free subs. Also the voice acting for dubs sucks and they 'American-ize' the dialog.
Isn't that basically embezzlement?
no, they paid for a streaming service, and CR puts money into produce more shows their fans may want, this was one of the suit's plan to make their Netflix Originals, unfortunately it was "current year" and instead of "Cyberpunk: Edgerunners" ya got this instead
The issue with High Guardian was that it wanted to have its cake and eat it too.
It wanted big, elaborate setpieces but it lacked the budget to do them and the knowledge of how to do them on the cheap.
It wanted deeplore and story but it couldn't manage to make any of its episodes endearing.
It wanted to be mature and progressive but ended up creatively bankrupt and bland because it never mined its own background for good ideas.
The ideal HGS is Cromartie High School, not RWBY or Harry Potter. More spics and retards, not less.
I hate that now I want Fantasy Cromartie Highschool
Be the change you want to see in the world. It's cheapo animated and the writing's meant to be stupid, so if you can get like five guys together you could do it.
The real reason is because of the bad trailer. That's it. First impressions are extremely important, and the shitty trailer caused an absolute internet shitstorm.
SU was made before internet outrage was truly a thing so it got off easy on that end, and She-ra haters made the mistake of centering their outrage around Adora not wearing revealing enough armor, something unpalatable to normies. But High Guardian Spice's trailer was universally reviled, for it's lack of anything good to say about the series and instead just bragging about how stunning and brave it is that all the writers were dykes with dyed hair.
>I-Its only the trailer guys! The actual show isn't dogshit, I swear!
Nice cope.
I never said that, homosexual. The show is shit, but so is She-ra and SU. I was just explaining why HGS has more of a bias against it compared to the other two equally awful shows.
ONCE A MONTH I TAKE A MAGIC POTION THAT LETS ME BE THE REAL ME
It's so hamfisted. I saw somewhere on youtube someone did their own version of the scene and it was so much better even if still had troon shit in it.
Also I thought new magic didn't have any cost or drawback.
It's fucking idiotic to try and apply trans logic in a setting where magic lets you freely shapeshift and transform.
You don't understand, anon. Magic in that world has limitations, too! The trans experience is real! Ignore the casual teleportation, healing water that can literally cure anything, or a spell that can cause a sword to never, ever break. A PENIS THOUGH? THAT SHIT NEEDS CONSTANT MAINTENCE.
god she is such pure sex. PURE SEX i say!
First thing I thought of is trans Link in sailor moon transformation.
Wasn't the creator working on some other show or something? Some people speculated it was her yaoi side series of comics
She's constantly begging for commission work on Twitter so I'm assuming whatever she had in the pipeline was canned following how badly HGS was received
What would you get from her if you could? I'm thinking super fetishy ftm yaoi.
If it's the tranny doing commissions I'd request some detrans porn, I hear the ftms love it.
Eh. After a certain point you can literally just engage with them as a weird type of alt woman and you get away with it.
Foot fetish art
it was literally
>crunchyroll subscribers pay the subscription for anime
>find out money funded something not anime
>reeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
Weebs got mad about it
I gave it a shot. Crunchyroll is cheap as fuck, apparently. It's fitting that their rise to fame was pirating anime, followed by delivering poor quality distributions when it reached legitimacy.
>over 30 posts in
>no rosemary or sage porn posted yet
Proud of you Cinemaphile but also disappointed.
>all that text of crybaby shit
Blame Kate Leth.
nu-Ra and SU have substantial hatedoms too. But they also have a fair amount of people who praise the shows since despite having glaring flaws, they have moments and qualities that elevate them beyond "crudely animated children's show", something HGS lacks
It's a combination of the fact that schizos absolutely fucking hate trannies so much that they will pissshit themselves in rage for years over anything that's made by trannies...... AND also the fact that objectively, the show just kind of sucks.
So unlike She-Ra (a good show) or Steven Universe (a good show with a kind of shitty ending), the part of the fandom that would turn around and bulwark the series against criticism doesn't exist. So it's just pure hatred all the time forever into oblivion.
A good case study, alternatively, is something like Batman v Superman Dawn of Justice: an objectively terrible movie that nonetheless has legions of apologetic fanboys because Zach Snyder is probably unintentionally/unwantedly like an avatar for anti-tranny-ness.
So you need to be one of two things:
> Not a Tranny
or
> Your show is actually pretty good
If you can manage one of the two, you'll get some angry ranty video essays that end up not really mattering, but if you can't do either, then you're the new posterchild for angry chuds on the internet for the next few years.
She-Ra is made by a hindsight tranny and Steven Universe was made by a non-binary woman, which is just as hated as a tranny on this board. So the only other conclusion is that both those shows are good which... I guess is debatable.
People say Ocean Gem is a 10/10 mark in the series, yet, a lot of the conversation with Steven and Lapis on top of the water tower is just as cringey as some of the dialogue in HGS. Especially the awkward "No prob, Bob" exchange.
?si=NGERXoiJb5DLigoP
That Connie to the right still gets me. How the heck could that and the one next to it be the same character.
Rebecca's "artistic freedom" bullshit causes the characters to go off model in every shot, once you notice it it's really fucking distracting
>>So you need to be one of two things:
>> Not a Tranny
>>or
>>Your show is actually pretty good
This is immediately proven wrong by Amazing Digital Circus being both made by a tranny AND complete dogshit, but it's still widely loved through the sheer power of Pomni's dicky
You say that like a show isn't an immediate 10/10 if it's offering clownnie.
TADG is just another indie pilot in a sea of them with its standout point being that it had enough shapes and colors to attract children. Autism itself is the bulwark
>dicky
Pomni is 25
Terrified while lost in space. Cute stuff.
Do we actually see their swimsuits in an episode, or is this just an intro tease?
Just an intro tease. We sort of get swimsuits when they transform into mermaids but that's a whole other thing.
Because it's a "Crunchyroll original" that is basically early 2010's tumblr: The show. Weeb reactionaries obviously weren't going to take kindly to something with a calart's style that had overt LGBTQ representation. Really didn't help that they show the creators face in the promo material which they're the exact type of people CR watchers would make fun of.
She-Ra had more stuff going for it ex the character designs and characters themselves same SU too maybe idk I never watched it but HGS doesn't have any legs to stand on. I do like it tho since it has a nostalgic amateur fanfic feel no other cartoon has. I just wish we could get another season of Onix Equinox...
Have you heard of trans magic anon?
Okay but baby making sex with Olive
>People shit on this show so much, but I honestly can't tell the difference between the writing in this show and the writing in something like Netflix's She-Ra or some episodes of Steven Universe
Anon. I want to fucking strangle you for even thinking those words. If you can't tell the difference in writing between She-Ra, Steven Universe, and High Guardian Spice; you are a perfect example as to why democracy has failed.
Those shows are just as lame, you probably just want to fuck one of the characters so you don't think so.
Just because I want to passionately breed Entrapta doesn't mean I tolerate crap writing. She-Ra may have had its fair share of blunders, but it also had pacing, arcs, well written characters that kept the plot moving, etc. All of these are things that High Guardian Spice lacked. Whether because of too many cooks in the kitchen, CrunchyRoll incompetence, or some other reason is up for debate.
Can't speak for SU.
Well said, Hordak
>People shit on this show so much,
NO.
they shit on the trailer, by the time it came out no one remembered it existed
and it was mostly about weebs angry their money was spent on this instead of anime
Pomni moggs this show.
Goose is the better troon.
Personally I prefer her pre-circus work (little runmo is my personal fav) but I’m happy she was able to find so much success with this project.
2 years worth of delays for an extremely mediocre product with even more inconsistent world building than SU and an even more obnoxious and retarded protagonist that early Steven.
Legit swings a sword around in a crowded market place and gets pissy that the person she almost decaptiated is annoyed at her for being a spaz.
Also one of the plots of one of the episode is said spaz protagonist damages her mother's heirloom sword and is sad because she was careless and damaged something that was important to her, is then reassured that it's ok because her mother also damaged it, by being competent and saving people.
This with really inconsistent, flat animation and insanely bad VA work.
It's shit on worse than SU because it's legit just worse than it.
Here's my volcanically hot take
I think Raye Rodriguez actually has potential as a writer and possibly even a showrunner. They just need actual practice first and HGS was their first real project that they were not experienced enough to handle
Also having a better team working under them, and not misandrists like Kate Leth
Isn't this the show that literally had a tranny groom a kid in it?
Don't believe everything you read on twitter, anon
yeah, an ftm grooms a femboy into being an mtf because he is feminine
Sex with Rosemary
She poops on Sage's chest (noncon).
The first trailer and Crunchyroll using that "pay the animators" money to make a faux anime. The money and Crunchyroll sitting on it, killing whatever heat the big defenders had, most likely soured it to the usual goons.
It did have defenders, but the highest it ever got was "But Crunchyroll and the development was hard!, But it was still an inadvertent parody of "their" shows.
>Netflix's She-Ra or some episodes of Steven Universe
Those were godawful abominations as well.
If you ever see a mlp fan talking about “hasdrones”, something like this is what they mean. I mindless drone who will schlop up any garbage that’s fed to them since they are completely incapable of discerning the quality of a piece of media.
>but I honestly can't tell the difference between the writing in this show and the writing in something like Netflix's She-Ra or some episodes of Steven Universe.
You must be incredibly dumb, then.
It's about context. Shows like She-Ra or Steven Universe are treated like western cartoons and western cartoons as a medium has a fairly low standards. HGS on the other hand was put on an anime streaming service, a place that comparably has much higher standards and actual good LGBT series. It's all about context.
>anime streaming service, a place that comparably has much higher standards
Of course mate, nothing but the best gets love from anime fans does it?
Now if you'll excuse me I'm off to enjoy "isekai child harem #2341" the latest episodes out on crunchyroll now