Why was it considered evil that Anakin slaughtered a whole village of sandpeople? They tortured his mother for over a month and she died in his arms.
 Shopping Cart Returner Shirt $21.68 |
 DMT Has Friends For Me Shirt $21.68 |
Shopping Cart Returner Shirt $21.68 |
Even the children?
They'd grow up to just as filthy as their parents. Some cultures are just evil and shouldn't exist
Racism is evil. Separating one another on lines like race, sex or religion only leads to division.
We like to think we do things a bit better down under - there's a reason they call us the lucky country.
We say for those who've come across the seas we've boundless plains to share.
>Racism is
a israeli word made up just 100 years ago
it doesn't exist
racial ingrouping is natural
Was just reading Mariel of Redwall. A mousemaid with amnesia is being brought to Redwall to be with her own kind "who will naturally be better at taking care of her"
Even as late at the early 90's, this was a normal supposition that was reflected in literature.
Yes, they actively participate in their parents barbarian practices.
the boba fett show showed that yes, the children would participate in their random torture of innocents
especially the children
Intent matters and he was doing it out of hatred.
If he’d done it solely because he genuinely believed they were a threat that had to be exterminated and done it dispassionately, it wouldn’t have been a problem.
was it even portrayed as evil though? only the misguided jedi thought it was evil. pretty sure George Lucas thinks the Sith are based
Anakin is literally crying and foaming at his mouth during his autistic spergout. It's definitely framed that way. Padme can only watch and give him some banal reassurance.
Well it was reasonable for him to kill the men, but the women? And the children, too? He slaughtered them like animals dude.
>animals
I can't even say their name
No more of this, 3P0.
Take out an entire fricking tribe?
Bruh he even hated them
the women were knowledgeable and complacent of their husband's actions and knowingly reared young who they knew would and were fine with, continuing that way of life. in this context I believe it is permissible. the children...debatable. it would hinge on if those kids were able to adapt into society. maybe they're unable to and their very instinct makes them a danger. if that's true and well known, then they're permitted death as well.
If he didn't kill the children one of them would kill him someday.
imagine if he had raped those women instead
because he's not the state of israel
Fricking israelites.
Anakin had the right to defend himself
Who said he didn't?
It genuinely is a shame that israelites are the only ones allowed to slaughter the sandpeople that torment their people with impunity.
It wasn't so much that the act was evil. It was more that he did it in a fit of rage, giving in to his emotions, and then it became a source of never ending guilt for him. His inability to control his emotions and that well of unresolved guilt made it very easy for the Palpster to manipulate him.
While that's true the jedi telling him to suppress his concern for his mother who is clearly in danger is peak sociopath behaviour. His anger issues are the result of Obi Wan's not letting him vent about anything. Anyone in his place would have exploded after seeing what happened to his mother and how avoidable it was. The jedi were just lucky to not have been nearby or we would have seen order 66 in the second movie.
I'd have yelled at the sand people for not letting me help them do that to my mother. Then I would have killed them. Probably raped the sand women too.
They weren't tell him to suppress his emotions, you idiot. Yoda told him:
>train yourself to LET GO
It is a much different thing.
https://www.vipassanadhura.com/lettinggo.html
To suppress your emotions leaves you at their mercy, you are fighting a battle against them, and you will always lose. You must be mindful of your feeling. Always be mindful of the living force. And let go of these emotions when they threaten to take over you. Your mentality re. the Jedi being the bad guy is misguided, you have already failed to understand. If you were a Jedi Padawan, I would not recommend you for the Trials.
not him but telling a child
>just don't think about your mother suffering in slavery bro let it go
is as moronic as it sounds
yoda was failing to consider the fact anakin was far older than the typical youngling when brought to the order and failed to adjust his teachings accordingly
>Just undo your emotions bro
The jedi mumbo jumbo is useless sophistry in this case. This is why they groom kids from an age they wouldn't even be able to remember their parents. They just don't know how to deal with people who aren't blank slates.
Ask yourself why Obi Wan and Qui Gon never spoke about their parents or family. The Jedi expected him to give up all his connections and he refused to.
They don't have a family to remember. All the jedi recruit kids below the age of 3.
>All the jedi recruit kids below the age of 3.
how do they find them?
what kind of parents give away their 3 yo kids?
Anger issues come from different places.
One of them is Anakin clearly surpassing Obi wan in every physical sense, being more gifted, better in tune with the force, reacting faster and (in Anakin's view) making better decisions.
Obi wan feels this too and has adopted a condescending, dick measuring behavior with anakin. He's clearly out of his depth by ep 2.
So natural teenage desire to be the best, very real sense that he's being held back and that obiwan doesn't understand him (this is true), and you can see why he's frustrated.
The scene where he confesses is even more terrifying.
Anakin is at least understandable in his actions. Padme may actually be insane
>Padme... I'm a mass murderer. I can't even right now....
>Oh you poor baby!
>I even killed children!
>...I am so fricking wet right now, Anni, you have no idea.
>Sadistic child groomer is happy when their victim becomes likewise sadistic
No shit
Prequels really are kino as frick.
The entire thing about the Anakin situation is that it was rigged from the start.
>born into slavery
>at age 7 or something already yippee's a whole capital ship with who knows how many neimodians onboard
>has to leave mother behind in slavery knowing full well these rich prick jedi won't lift a finger to save her
>Kenobi is a total wet blanket dick to him the entire time
>wants to frick Padme and has to do it covertly for fear of ... well idk what, what if he "quits" the jedi or turns, do the jedi just imprison him or kill him or what?!
>everyone's a massive dick to him even though he can crush them like tin cans
etc...
to frick Padme and has to do it covertly for fear of ... well idk what, what if he "quits" the jedi or turns, do the jedi just imprison him or kill him or what?!
He would just be expelled from the Jedi. You can leave of your own accord but Anakin would never do that
The Dooku thing is a bit unclear since he's off the radar as soon a he quit the order. So maybe he went into hiding as soon as he quit so they don't pursue him or keep an eye on him.
Leaving the order seems to be a very rare thing that is not even on the table.
Based on their doctrine I don't see them leaving a strong force user roaming around and for sure falling to the dark side gradually.
>Based on their doctrine I don't see them leaving a strong force user roaming around and for sure falling to the dark side gradually.
From my point of view the Jedi are evil
idk how they're handling it in the nu-lore but the old EU dooku was allowed to leave voluntarily but this is tempered by the claim that he was one of only 20 masters to voluntarily leave the order in 20,000 years, the implication seems to be they truly don't do anything unless they go full darth immediately.
what truly confuses me is how deep into hair splitting they've gotten when it comes to love/relaionships, because if I understand correctly you could absolutely have a family and still not technically form attachments in the sense they b***h about. I don't understand why they keep trying to justify it and not just have them rewrite the damn interpretation of the code
Ki-adi mundi got a pass becuse his species were dying out, or something like that. There weren't many so he was allowed to help male a few more.
Getting married is not necessary to procreate. There's clearly favouritism among council members.
the whole
>no romance!
thing isn't actually a hard rule but one enforced because the jedi were lazy buttholes unwilling to expend effort on teaching their pupils healthy emotional behavior without unhealthy attachment, so they frowned upon behavior that could easily lead to attachment
>lazy buttholes unwilling to expend effort on teaching their pupils healthy emotional behavior without unhealthy attachment
This. Liam Neeson seemed the only guy capable of being more than a jedi drone and teach something of value, and because of that he was too discriminated by the jedi council.
It might have been a cultural requirement. Didn't he have 3 wives? He still clearly spent the vast majority of his time doing jedi stuff.
>I don't understand why
The reason is staring right at your face.
The jedi were "corrupt". Not in the sense that they are evil, but they have lost their way. Too busy with rules and regulations and protocol and not concerned with the "living Force" and humility.
That's what brought the order down. They just turned into buttholes.
That's why they needed to go and unironically Anakin fulfilled the prophecy by first wiling THEM out then wiping the sith out (including himself). The entire board needed to be wiped clean and started over.
>I don't understand why they keep trying to justify it and not just have them rewrite the damn interpretation of the code
Are we talking about Jedi or Catholics?
Somehow the millennials ruined star wars
>has to leave mother behind in slavery knowing full well these rich prick jedi won't lift a finger to save her
this always has bothered the frick out of me. the jedi aren't above meddling in "mundane" shit you would think they'd be smart enough to save their savior's mother from outright slavery. but no even disney only has padme try to save her a couple years later
>well idk what, what if he "quits" the jedi or turns, do the jedi just imprison him or kill him or what?!
he'd just be made to leave the order lmao, dooku chose to quit and they did nothing and they believed he might even start a new rival order before he SITH'd himself
with the prequels one can't squint or a lot of shit sounds stupid as hell
>wants to frick Padme and has to do it covertly for fear of ... well idk what, what if he "quits" the jedi or turns, do the jedi just imprison him or kill him or what?!
He's more of a convert jedi, since he was partly raised outside of the order. He's in many ways a more fervent believer than his peers.
When he strays and does bad, the guilt is massive. He is conflicted in his actions and thinking.
He also believes in pretty crazy stuff like "universal love".
It's almost like George Lucas is a thieving fraud that got very lucky and had very talented people all around him, and most of these movies are glorified toy commercials. Huh. Weird.
Suck another Black person dick, mouse cuck
I hate the israeliteney sequels even more than the Lucas dogshit you fricking moronic subhuman. You do know Lucas literally loves and worships nigs right? Your hero is a fricking fraud shekelschemer and you're a fat permavirgin lemming following behind him eating his shit. I suggest you have a nice day.
Nogger detected
finally would be some peace without your useless racist losers piggybacking off the achievements of complete strangers that share you pigmentation
Keep crying
Yup, keep crying about white extinction, anti-white discrimination, [insert euphemism for blacks here], liberals, etc. All you can do
You’re screaming at the wall, Black personcel
Within a century 99% of whites are going to flee from countries like the U.S. because they'll be forced to accept there's simply no fixing Black folk. Whatever countries they flee to will thrive as the U.S. rots and crumbles while those who remain know how to do absolutely nothing besides b***h and whine about whitey.
>not evil to ignore slavery
>evil to kill killers
Jedi are impotent c**ts
It's funny how they had to add "killing younglings" scene to have any proof that siths and vader are actually evil and audience shouldn't root for them
the chud mind on full display
yikes
Whites are the second least violent race after east asian people. You gotta be black and therefore dumb and super violent
Sand status?
Coarse, rough and everywhere.
I hate it so much, bros.
Jedis aren't supposed to give into emotions. They're supposed to be Vulcan-like with total control over their feelings because giving into emotions is how you end up going to the dark side.
Because he killed children.
9/11 was too close
Libtards love Black folk so of course they think it’s evil.
Everyone else thought it was based and justified to kill those savages.
I don't recall people caring much. Even Padme cared about Anakin's emotional distress, not the sand people.
It wasn't that it was evil, it was that he acted purely on rage, which is something that the Dark Side feeds off of.
i.e. it wasn't so much evil in and of itself, it was that Anakin opened himself up to further exploitation to the Dark Side and Palpatine by operating on rage. If he'd just killed who needed to kill there might no have been a problem.
Though Padme didn't seem to have a problem with it, lol.
The sand Black folk deserved it.
Alderaan also deserved it.
Because Anakin had to turn evil by the end of Episode III.
>be some random sand kid
>know nothing except sand and the protection of your mum and dad
>die horribly after being cut in half by a laser sword
>have to watch your own mother get cut into pieces before you go
Because he didn’t kill Watto
He did the right thing
It’s also implied that she was raped, especially with how they had her tied up.
sand people are obsessed with water in any form. semen is 59% water.
>Butcher sand children
>"To be angry is to be human."
>Butcher child soldiers
>"You killed younglings! You're going down a path I can't follow!"
Why is Padme like this?
stop equating the actions of some jedi with all followers of the jedi religion