>Earth is dying
>wormhole opens in solar system
>NASA sends astronauts through wormhole to find new planet for humanity
>one of these astronauts succeeds and humans leave Earth behind
>it's revealed at the end of the film that the wormhole was created by the far descendants of humanity that left earth
If the wormhole was created by the descendants of the humans that left earth, and the only way for those descendants to be alive is by their ancestors using the wormhole to get to the new planet, how could they have been the ones to create it?
Because love is the one thing that transcends dimensions of time and space.
>those digits
Posting 4 love
Checked
Basically they wanted to crash this plot with no survivors.
They could have just not explained it, and it would be fine
via spying on childs bedroom? Seems like pedophilia is "the only thing that transcends dimensions of time and space."
I mean did you see what Mackenzie Foy looked like?
I like breasts though
Smol breasts are best.
Not my favourite film, but I honestly don't get this criticism of the film. This is just Coopers characters personal take on things, yet everyone treats it like the actual canon explanation.
Racism too.
It's a time loop. Don't think too much about it, not even Nolan did it anyways lol
no, no it isnt. Cooper could be wrong, it could be ayys trolling us
didn't understand anything from that movie ending tbh I was just there for the vibe
They have access to a higher dimension which can perceive time like it's a physical dimension.
If the wormhole closed at the end of the movie, how did he fly that little ship back to Anne Hathaway's planet?
Uhhh don't think about it, or the fact that she'd be dead for 60 years by the time he gets therd
Also we’re meant to forget that he was flying through a black hole in just his space suit and was somehow fine. Gravity so strong light can’t escape =frick it. Hawking radiation strong enough to turn titanium in ion vapor = frick it. No Nolan, frick you.
Love,bro
Love got him through it
they went through an artificial wormhole at the beginning, you find it hard to believe the artificial tesseract inside the blackhole was artificially created to allow cooper safe passage?
She experienced similar time dilation.
The wormhole is still open.
The tesseract inside the black hole collapsed, not the wormhole.
Uh, could you explain that in English, doc?
Read about the Competence Crisis. It's already over.
The tesseract inside the black hole collapsed, not the wormhole
sounds gay tbh senpai
thats cuz you got gay ears homie
You all got further than I did.
>Where's my daughter, what have you done with her? I cant imagine what I'd do... my daughter means everything to me
>Don't worry here she is.
>Hey Dad
>Hey sweetie, so glad you're okay I can't imagine living without you
>So anyway, you wanna be an astronaut, you'll probably never see your daughter again
>Sure thing boss, sign me up.
>Spend the rest of your life with your daughter
>But she’ll probably suffer greatly and die early unless someone like you leaves to find a new home for humanity
>someone like you
Greasy dusted alcoholic shot into space with no re-training?
>Don't worry that baby handles like a late model pickup plowing through a corn field after 4-5 beers on the porch with pops.
I'd suggest with the stakes so high it's a better idea to send someone in their prime, and thank them for the scotch.
There was no one else, the movie hammers this in pretty hard. They thought it was intervention from the same beings that put the wormhole there. Also, the scene with Murphy's teacher was to highlight that the general populace isn't interested in space travel, so they're not going to have many, if any candidates who have actually had experience flying real missions.
Cooper was the test pilot for the same ships they wanted to use.
The plot implodes in the third act
I liked the part where they didn't think about time dilation for 2 fricking seconds before beaming down to Narnia
They talked about it and picked a direct path down to save as much time as they could. They just didn't anticipate getting their engine flooded.
They showed you the fifth dimension (it’s a common misconception we live in the third, we actually live in the fourth.) in the fifth dimension time is irrelevant.
Pretty sure we live in more than one dimension, my non-flat, non-linear friend.
Always funny to me how brainlets cannot grasp something as simple as a stable time loop.
>Find a time machine
>Use it to travel to future where building a time machine is easy
>Build a time machine and send it back for yourself to find
How did the time machine come to be? It just did, OK?
It's stupid, was stupid, and will always be stupid.
>enter separate dimension where time is irrelevant
>cause event in regular dimension from inside separate dimension
There you go, its exactly what happens in movie. The regular dimension has no effect on the 5th dimension so its not subject to causality
It's called the grandfather paradox and it was never solved, you are the actual moron.
Proper answer: all they did in the movie didn't matter and it would've solved itself, anyhow the movie is fricking moronic, they are able to build a giant space-colony ship yet they can't just have it float into space until the virus dies off and they can begin cultivating again.
The blight was going to permanently change their atmosphere.
The last people to starve will be the first to suffocate
Never stated in the movie and the principle doesn't change, they could've simply waited it out.
Actually, they where never in any danger, instead of being morons they could've just used those years to build multiple colonies and get people on board instead of throwing everything under the carpet.
But they can't get the colonies off the ground without taking readings from inside a black hole.
Threadly reminder that 'stable time loops' are TOTAL shit. They should only be allowed in comedies.
Think of it like this.
It's called Novikov self-consistency principle. Basically you are thinking of events in terms of cause and consequence, when there is no such thing, they just have to be consistent with each other, as they are at the same the cause and consequence of one another. Nolan hints at this principle when Cooper tells Murphy whatever can happen, will happen.
Which has to mean that the wormhole (and time loop) just exists because it's a built-in part of the universe. It's dumb, not clever.
Why is it dumb? It is as if the bank only loaned you some money if they knew you would pay it back. Someone in the future still has to build the wormhole and send it back in time. Nolan uses the same idea in Tenet with Pattinson's character. If you assume time is just another dimension then there is no reason to assume this can't be logically consistent.
>It's dumb
how so?
do you complain about 3-dimensional structures that have stuff built into them?
>moving really fast speeds up time, but only just for you
yeah i am culling bullshit
the film is a half assed copy of the first book in the manifold series but with fewer octopuses
i suggest reading that instead as TARS is the only good thing in interstellar
he explained very clearly
>nasa got defunded because they refused to drop bombs on starving people
It's time to admit this film wasn't that great
>>nasa got defunded because they refused to drop bombs on starving people
Air force should have dropped a bomb on NASA
It was time to admit it wasn't great when it misunderstood relativity and ruined sci fi forever.
>If the wormhole was created by the descendants of the humans that left earth, and the only way for those descendants to be alive is by their ancestors using the wormhole to get to the new planet, how could they have been the ones to create it?
it's called a time loop you fricking twat. Do you go around asking how a tire is able to connect to itself?
It's a closed time loop. Deterministic, so they always did X, which always led to Y.
The first time loop we didn't see was Anne Hathaway or somebody else establishing the first colony, presumably humanity surviving on the edge of extinction before they get their shit together and open a wormhole, then creating the timeloop
How did nobody in 40 posts get that?
that doesn't make any sense.
the time loop is a pre-existing structure in the universe. it was created when the universe was created.
According to what
And yes it does make sense, why wouldn't it
the whole idea of a time loop is that nothing creates it. It just exists as part of the universe.
There is no "first" loop, because that fails to understand how time works.
>There is no "first" loop
This. There is only one time loop.
Why would you assume that happened if you didn't see it? There's no reason to believe she could ever establish the colony without the wormhole, and if that was there then the time loop was already in place.
Jesus christ I can't believe how moronic the new generations are, this is actually scary
One part I do like is that at the end when he sees his daughter and she's like 90 years old she doesn't really give a shit and talks to him for like two minutes then tells him to leave because she wants to be with her actual family that didn't abandon her. I actually do like that part and I'm not joking
>If the wormhole was created by the descendants of the humans that left earth, and the only way for those descendants to be alive is by their ancestors using the wormhole to get to the new planet, how could they have been the ones to create it?
that's what every time travel story boils down to, it's genre fiction, very cliche
weeeeah my science fiction has fiction in it
Love TARS
Bravo Nolan
>anon can't even into basic bootstrap paradoxes
watch dark, you clearly need to.
He dies in the crash of the opening scene and the entire rest of the movie is his fever dream as he's passing away. Nolan explained this in the director's commentary. Please do your research next time