He acted like a moron and drove her way. It was entirely his own fault. Rowling said if he didn't become a death eater homosexual he would have gotten Lily
I believe this. Idiots on this site will try to claim that James was an "alpha" or some shit, and that it was therefore a foregone conclusion, but, judging by Lily's hippy personality, I think she would have ended up with Snape had he not joined the wizarding equivalent of the SS. Certain girls are just nice, and I think it's clear from the story that she did love Snape. The only thing that could have ruined their relationship was Snape rejecting the kindness that Lily embodied, which is exactly what happened. No woman is going to want to be with a man who views her and her people as subhuman, unless she's a bit dim and lacking in all self respect.
tl;dr Cinemaphile's view of the world is only right some of the time
Perhaps, if we go only by what's exactly written in the story, but to truly read a book if you need to go beyond what's written and take a look at the author's intentions, to dive into the author's mind. I personally think it's pretty telling that this love triangle was written in this specific way. You know, the 'special' girl falling in love with the bad boy and turning him around (or himself changing for her). It begs the question: if she believed she could 'fix' James, why not Snape? It's a common staple in love stories written by women that the loser has one irredeemable trait even when he's missing most of the qualities women truly find attractive, as if to excuse their lack of interest.
This isn’t what the movie showed, which is telling about the book. I think she only backpedaled when girl creamed their pants over Malfoy. Honestly, from a lifetime of experience, the worst thing you want to do is listen to a woman talk about what she wants as a perfect man. It’s almost always contradictory to what they really want.
Hermione is mid nerd girl, she's never described as particularly pretty except at the Ball. Harry found her too nagging to be with her. But she reminded Ron just enough of his mother to find her endearing. Malfoy had no reason to be attracted to her. Also remember Ron is a 6 feet tall jock who was handsome enough to get that other girl mad for him.
3 months ago
Anonymous
Mafloy had a bizarre fixation on bullying her in spite of barely interacting
3 months ago
Anonymous
I daresay he did because she was Harry's friend and an easy target (mudblood). I don't remember him going out of his way to mess with her alone.
3 months ago
Anonymous
His fixation with Harry was equally bizarre in the first and second years. It only makes sense after Harry steals his family’s slave.
3 months ago
Anonymous
Anon, I want you to think back to school and think of that one person you absolutely hated because they represented everything you didn't like. That's what Harry was for Malfoy.
3 months ago
Anonymous
Harry had no values in the wizarding world and only chose not-Slytherin because Malfoy was a dick to the ginger kid he met on the train.
3 months ago
Anonymous
Malfoy was jealous of Harry's fame and the fact that he constantly would one up him.
3 months ago
Anonymous
In the books Ron isn't tall he is short and stocky like the twins should be. In the books harry becomes the six food chad he grows over summer. Little did they know Radcliffe has the israeli jeans and Grint didn't
3 months ago
Anonymous
*Genes wtf did I put jeans I'm moronic
3 months ago
Anonymous
>In the books Ron isn't tall he is short and stocky like the twins should be.
You're wrong. Charlie is the stocky one. Ron is ever described as gangly. >Bill: tall >Charlie: stocky >Percy: tall >twins: stocky >Ron: tall
Follows wacky wizard rules
3 months ago
Anonymous
Ron was tall, he was taller than both of them by Chamber of Secrets. What the movies don't get is that Harry was pretty tall too but Radcliffe is a manlet so they couldn't pull that off.
3 months ago
Anonymous
Hermione is canon pretty
She attracts Krum and McClaggen. Even Harry
Ron is the ugly one
3 months ago
Anonymous
Hermione is pretty though. Thing is that she's "plain" in that she doesn't do her hair or wear makeup and flattering clothes and whatnot. When she actually dolls up, everyone takes notice, including Harry and Ron.
3 months ago
Anonymous
She used literal magic to get pretty. Every girl can look good with that.
3 months ago
Anonymous
Only thing she used magic for was to fix the buck teeth she had. Thing is, Krum liked her before she had her teeth magically fixed.
3 months ago
Anonymous
No, she said she used some potions for her hair and skin. Also used makeup. She also said it's too much work to keep it up daily so she wouldn't bother with it.
3 months ago
Anonymous
As far as hair goes, that's no different than someone using hair gel. Potions for skin is is most likely akin to lotion. Unless they changed her actual physical appearance, that's no different than a woman who simply dolls up.
3 months ago
Anonymous
That's my point, but since it's magic it could be much more effective. There are naturally pretty girls in the series like Cho, Ginny, and Fleur, since they're the only ones JKR goes out of her way to describe as pretty.
3 months ago
Anonymous
The only time she specifically did that was in book four for the ball. Honestly I think it's safe to assume most women in the universe do it often though
3 months ago
Anonymous
How do other than a potion that shortened her overnight? Her parents were dentists and could haved ground them down.
She regrets not writing Harry/Hermione actually, since their relationship dynamic was better than Harry Ginny and only morons think 2 people who argue all the time over insignificant shit is the basis for a good relationship (Ron/Hermione). Draco/Hermione is purely the product of moronic fangirls who self inserted as Hermione who obviously love bad boys
>oooomg snapeee you’re like totally my best friend but your politics worry me fr >I wouuuldve totally picked you if you weren’t such a chuddy omg >but nevermind, no judgement. you do you. btw wanna see some pictures of me and James’ son?
This is exactly what a mall hippy would say. Lilly was clearly an actual hippy, with principles, and would therefore have genuinely been unable to reconcile her love of Snape with his ideas concerning racial supremacy.
The thing is is that she is lying and just using her feminine wiles to try and change his political opinions, she’d be with the handsome jock boy all the same.
Thing is your average 11 year old doesn't know that and is going to be nervous and scare to tell that hat what they want. Hermione was the only one said to have told the hat off because it wanted to put her in Ravenclaw
>White supremacist mutt chud drives his qt mutt childhood friend away by calling her a Black personhomosexual for standing between him and his white chad bully
What did jk mean by this?
a teenage boy liking a teenage girl 3 years apart?
what a pedophile
I want you morons to sit down and think about the differences between a boy near the end of puberty and entering adulthood and a girl at the beginning of puberty and nowhere near adulthood.
I dont see any Black folk
Because it takes place in the good old days before wizard antifa ruined everything
He acted like a moron and drove her way. It was entirely his own fault. Rowling said if he didn't become a death eater homosexual he would have gotten Lily
>snape would have been harrys dad
I believe this. Idiots on this site will try to claim that James was an "alpha" or some shit, and that it was therefore a foregone conclusion, but, judging by Lily's hippy personality, I think she would have ended up with Snape had he not joined the wizarding equivalent of the SS. Certain girls are just nice, and I think it's clear from the story that she did love Snape. The only thing that could have ruined their relationship was Snape rejecting the kindness that Lily embodied, which is exactly what happened. No woman is going to want to be with a man who views her and her people as subhuman, unless she's a bit dim and lacking in all self respect.
tl;dr Cinemaphile's view of the world is only right some of the time
>Cinemaphile's view of the world is only right some of the time
>Cinemaphile is one person
we are all one
Perhaps, if we go only by what's exactly written in the story, but to truly read a book if you need to go beyond what's written and take a look at the author's intentions, to dive into the author's mind. I personally think it's pretty telling that this love triangle was written in this specific way. You know, the 'special' girl falling in love with the bad boy and turning him around (or himself changing for her). It begs the question: if she believed she could 'fix' James, why not Snape? It's a common staple in love stories written by women that the loser has one irredeemable trait even when he's missing most of the qualities women truly find attractive, as if to excuse their lack of interest.
She tried to fix Snape, and she failed. Repeatedly. So she looked elsewhere and found James.
It's a book, she fails as much as the author wanted her to. That's my point in looking at the author's intentions.
This isn’t what the movie showed, which is telling about the book. I think she only backpedaled when girl creamed their pants over Malfoy. Honestly, from a lifetime of experience, the worst thing you want to do is listen to a woman talk about what she wants as a perfect man. It’s almost always contradictory to what they really want.
She probably regrets not writing HermionexMalfoy like 90% of her female readers wanted.
Malfoy and Harry are better pairs for Hermione than Ron
No real world Hermione ends up with a Ron
Hermione is mid nerd girl, she's never described as particularly pretty except at the Ball. Harry found her too nagging to be with her. But she reminded Ron just enough of his mother to find her endearing. Malfoy had no reason to be attracted to her. Also remember Ron is a 6 feet tall jock who was handsome enough to get that other girl mad for him.
Mafloy had a bizarre fixation on bullying her in spite of barely interacting
I daresay he did because she was Harry's friend and an easy target (mudblood). I don't remember him going out of his way to mess with her alone.
His fixation with Harry was equally bizarre in the first and second years. It only makes sense after Harry steals his family’s slave.
Anon, I want you to think back to school and think of that one person you absolutely hated because they represented everything you didn't like. That's what Harry was for Malfoy.
Harry had no values in the wizarding world and only chose not-Slytherin because Malfoy was a dick to the ginger kid he met on the train.
Malfoy was jealous of Harry's fame and the fact that he constantly would one up him.
In the books Ron isn't tall he is short and stocky like the twins should be. In the books harry becomes the six food chad he grows over summer. Little did they know Radcliffe has the israeli jeans and Grint didn't
*Genes wtf did I put jeans I'm moronic
>In the books Ron isn't tall he is short and stocky like the twins should be.
You're wrong. Charlie is the stocky one. Ron is ever described as gangly.
>Bill: tall
>Charlie: stocky
>Percy: tall
>twins: stocky
>Ron: tall
Follows wacky wizard rules
Ron was tall, he was taller than both of them by Chamber of Secrets. What the movies don't get is that Harry was pretty tall too but Radcliffe is a manlet so they couldn't pull that off.
Hermione is canon pretty
She attracts Krum and McClaggen. Even Harry
Ron is the ugly one
Hermione is pretty though. Thing is that she's "plain" in that she doesn't do her hair or wear makeup and flattering clothes and whatnot. When she actually dolls up, everyone takes notice, including Harry and Ron.
She used literal magic to get pretty. Every girl can look good with that.
Only thing she used magic for was to fix the buck teeth she had. Thing is, Krum liked her before she had her teeth magically fixed.
No, she said she used some potions for her hair and skin. Also used makeup. She also said it's too much work to keep it up daily so she wouldn't bother with it.
As far as hair goes, that's no different than someone using hair gel. Potions for skin is is most likely akin to lotion. Unless they changed her actual physical appearance, that's no different than a woman who simply dolls up.
That's my point, but since it's magic it could be much more effective. There are naturally pretty girls in the series like Cho, Ginny, and Fleur, since they're the only ones JKR goes out of her way to describe as pretty.
The only time she specifically did that was in book four for the ball. Honestly I think it's safe to assume most women in the universe do it often though
How do other than a potion that shortened her overnight? Her parents were dentists and could haved ground them down.
She regrets not writing Harry/Hermione actually, since their relationship dynamic was better than Harry Ginny and only morons think 2 people who argue all the time over insignificant shit is the basis for a good relationship (Ron/Hermione). Draco/Hermione is purely the product of moronic fangirls who self inserted as Hermione who obviously love bad boys
why the frick not Harry/Luna
That's mostly movie centric. Book Luna and Harry weren't really that close.
Luna is weird and crazy (as in mental) hippy chick
Female readers want HarryxMalfoy
nah hippie types like alpha chads more than incel types like snape
not my experience
joining the wizard and real SS is what got you mad pussy in the first place
>oooomg snapeee you’re like totally my best friend but your politics worry me fr
>I wouuuldve totally picked you if you weren’t such a chuddy omg
>but nevermind, no judgement. you do you. btw wanna see some pictures of me and James’ son?
Sound familiar
more women than men voted for hitler
That doesn’t make sense mathematically. The female voter turnout in 1930s Germany can’t have been anything to sneeze at.
This is exactly what a mall hippy would say. Lilly was clearly an actual hippy, with principles, and would therefore have genuinely been unable to reconcile her love of Snape with his ideas concerning racial supremacy.
The thing is is that she is lying and just using her feminine wiles to try and change his political opinions, she’d be with the handsome jock boy all the same.
There are PLENTY of hippie girls who get with the gaunt, lanky dude with long hair over your usual jock.
She never wanted him anyway. She was already wet for James when they were thirteen. He never had a chance.
he was an edgy moron and deserved getting cucked
The sorting hat cucked him hard.
The sorting hat is canonically a little b***h that does what you tell it to, Snape cucked himself.
Thing is your average 11 year old doesn't know that and is going to be nervous and scare to tell that hat what they want. Hermione was the only one said to have told the hat off because it wanted to put her in Ravenclaw
>White supremacist mutt chud drives his qt mutt childhood friend away by calling her a Black personhomosexual for standing between him and his white chad bully
What did jk mean by this?
Should I watch these movies?i just finished hogwarts legacy so I'm mildly interested
>call your waifu a stupid Black person
>wtf bros why didn't she pick me
Isn't that a common fetish in bfwm couples?
so it seems
Maybe don't call the girl you love a mudblood.
Just a little tip.
Not gonna lie, I think Krum just likes dicky. He was 17 while Hermione was 14.
a 17yo attracted to a 14yo?
I want you morons to sit down and think about the differences between a boy near the end of puberty and entering adulthood and a girl at the beginning of puberty and nowhere near adulthood.
Bad bait
Equally horny for one thing.
a teenage boy liking a teenage girl 3 years apart?
what a pedophile