It's genuinely bad in every way, costumes, story composition, writing, dialogues, cinematagrophy, score, pacing, cast outside of Sanji (ignoring that he's too big), Usopp and Nami
Genuinely just trash
Is it still kinda entertaining? Yeah because it's impossible to take an entire One Piece arc and put it in one or two episodes without it being entertaining. If you believe midly entertaining is what One Piece deserves, then go ahead and hype this trash
[...]
[...]
[...]
When will these morons shilling this trash frick off? It's been weeks by now.
Hi Critical Drinker
[...]
Hi Mauler
Reminder that drinking isn't a personality.
Haven’t seen it, looks like Netflix slop though. How the hell are they gonna afford literally anything after East Blue without it just looking like complete garbage? Skypia alone is gonna need like the budget of multiple marvel movies to look even ok, and I can’t even imagine how they’re gonna handle Water 7 or anything after that.
I'm scratching my head how Skypiea would be THAT expensive. Plus they can always change scope. Almost the entire second episode took place in a giant tent, instead of Buggy destroying a town. And it fricking worked.
>'m scratching my head how Skypiea would be THAT expensive
VFX are super expensive, majority of the budget of S1 went into CG for the fights, now imagine an arc where the fights are even crazier and the environment itself is also crazier.
Smoke machine plus Aztec props in a jungle. One set for angel island one set for upper yard. Enels final fight takes place on a boat. Not too out of the question
>Smoke machine
morons keep saying this without thinking that there's not a smoke machine big enough in the world to generate the amount necessary, so they will still need CG for the White Sea, and that they'll have to walk on solid clouds as well, which can't be done with a smoke machine because smoke ain't solid, so even more CG
>you just can’t put mist over water or the ground
Yeah you can though.
7 months ago
Anonymous
And it will look like shit, in order to make it look at least decent you'll need CG, and reminder that this is just the environment
7 months ago
Anonymous
I’m sure they’ll use CGI but you’re talking about in-universe prop wings and antennae, a few guys in coats with angel wings, and a white Detroiter. It really doesn’t seem that out of line at all
It's genuinely bad in every way, costumes, story composition, writing, dialogues, cinematagrophy, score, pacing, cast outside of Sanji (ignoring that he's too big), Usopp and Nami
Genuinely just trash
Is it still kinda entertaining? Yeah because it's impossible to take an entire One Piece arc and put it in one or two episodes without it being entertaining. If you believe midly entertaining is what One Piece deserves, then go ahead and hype this trash
>deserves
You say this like it hurts to have this in any way. We got this during a time when Oda was going on repeated breaks and still is, mind you. I don't enjoy every One Piece arc and I certainly don't enjoy all these breaks he keeps going on.
>You say this like it hurts to have this in any way.
The good ratings will encourage other Hollywood producers to make more shitty live action remakes (most of which won't include the contribution of the original writers) that won't do anything other than harm the image of the franchise and pander to morons who get filtered by the original because it's 2D.
Not to mention homosexuals like OP will keep plaguing places like this one by shilling this slop for free.
>The good ratings will encourage other Hollywood producers to make more shitty live action remakes
Which will be bad because...? >that won't do anything other than harm the image of the franchise
Why the frick do you care what normies think about the franchise? I thought you didn't want any normies into the series. >pander to morons who get filtered by the original because it's 2D.
Why do you care if they're only watching the live action instead of the original? >Not to mention homosexuals like OP will keep plaguing places like this one by shilling this slop for free.
You're telling me you'd rather threads upon threads of Bane and Sneed posting instead of threads like this?
The show isn't great and is being massively astroturfed everywhere by shills but why are you pretending that the original is some masterpiece when it is just some dumb kids show.
Honestly, I think most people who've tried to adapt manga and anime properties just overthink it.
All the One Piece people did was have faith that what works in the source material will still work in live action and consult the original author. There wasn't anyone going "We need to make it more like Guardians of the Galaxy to make it work!" Like they did for Bebop. They had something that was already popular and did their best adapt it into a different format.
All the behind the scenes vids constantly mention the manga and not the anime. I think this is crucial to adapt this shit correctly. Use the manga source material not the anime
you dont know what youre talking about kid. this is on the same level as japanese anime/manga adaptions, i'd say even worse just for the amount of background Blacks, which is not faithful
But it was solidly competent. A step above - several steps - any other anime adaptation I've seen. No Overtaken is a crime. What the frick, it ruined the entire scene.
It is definitely worth a watch. I was surprised how kino the first episode was and just continued watching. Majority of the casting choices were so perfect
>protagonist is a brown guy going around acting superior to everybody because he wants to rape, loot and murder
Defend this.
In the OP world you get branded a criminal for running the jolly roger, regardless of whether or not you committed any crime. Luffy could have avoided a lot of trouble if he >never once had a jolly roger, just called himself a sailor or trader >handed any of his defeated enemies to the WG as bounties
Reading the reviews on imdb >"Never watched anime in my life" >but >this is the best thing ever and totally better than cowboy bebop and I will proceed to watch the anime too
Truly a 25iq brownoid show for trannies. Kys shill.
I know it’s a kids show but it makes 0 sense for him to call himself a pirate. He never actually does pirate shit, ever. The only reason he’s wanted is because he runs around telling everyone he’s a criminal
[...]
In the OP world you get branded a criminal for running the jolly roger, regardless of whether or not you committed any crime. Luffy could have avoided a lot of trouble if he >never once had a jolly roger, just called himself a sailor or trader >handed any of his defeated enemies to the WG as bounties
It's a problem that's never really addressed in the manga too. Hell, Whitebeard never hurts civilians or attacks marines. By all accounts, he shouldn't be wanted by the WG either.
In Wanted, Oda’s cowboy story from before One Piece, the main character was just some guy who was considered a cowboy and the greatest gunman in the world just because he keeps beating people who challenge him because he’s got a poster for beating people for challenging him etc
He literally gets into fights with the marines and raids marine bases, what are you even talking about? The first thing he does is knock over a marine base, he gets his bounty for fighting the marines of Cocoyashi village, and the real concern of the bounty system and the world government is not to prevent crime, but to prevent people reaching Laugh Tale. The world government has basically outlawed free exploration anyways so adventuring does pretty much make you a pirate. And then besides Smoker they’re pursued by no one in the government until Water 7 because they literally declare open war against the WG. God you’re stupid
>the real concern of the bounty system and the world government is not to prevent crime, but to prevent people reaching Laugh Tale
Never explained or even hinted in the series. Go frick yourself for defending this shit. I could come up with dozens of examples of pirates in the series who were NEVER confirmed to have scuffled with the marines or WG or anything and they still had huge wanted posters.
How about Smoker’s entire stated motivation of keeping pirates out of the grand line? How about the dozens of times it’s been discussed research into the void century is punishable by death, and the government controlling the seas so they can hide a secret that will destroy them? This all besides the fact that, again, they had raided marine bases and assaulted marine captains before
Read my post entirely next time before responding. Even IF you agree Luffy deserves his bounty, dozens of other pirates don't. Free sailing on the grand line was never, ever stated to be a crime. Many "pirates" could have called themselves traders.
>uh wait a minute I…I only meant other pirates which I can name but won’t
Go ahead and name them. Luffy has a bounty from assaulting marine bases and marines, and the story reveals as it goes on that the government is primarily concerned with preventing travel towards the One Piece and discovery of the history of the void century which will destroy the world government
7 months ago
Anonymous
>the story reveals as it goes on that the government is primarily concerned with preventing travel towards the One Piece and discovery of the history of the void century which will destroy the world government
No, frick you, the series never hinted the 2 are linked at ALL.
The government magically puts a bounty on anyone who has a black jolly roger flag. Deal with it.
7 months ago
Anonymous
Whitebeard literally calls Sengoku and the government out over this with his dying words, that they’re scared of piracy because it leads to the one piece being found, which will start a catastrophic war and turn the world upside down. The Gorosei say the same thing later
He kinda disappears from the story after East Blue and doesn't really do much again until Impel Down, so I'm guessing the writers are gonna change things a lot next season to keep Buggy relevant to the story
>same idea as Fishmen means just a kid with antlers on
The fishmen where way more complex and detailed a make up job than Sweet Tooth kid. If anything this further points towards a midget in a fursuit.
Will this series stretch out the in-universe timeline, with the journey through Paradise taking place over years instead of months? Don't see how they could otherwise explain the aging of the cast.
They won’t have to talk about it, just like they barely talk about the timeline in the manga. Sure you’ve got your time skip but it’s just media it goes along not really on a real calendar. They’ll be fine just not saying anything
let's get one thing straight here
I wanna make sweet sugary love to aunt jemima
that's Ussop
no she makes Syrup
So do they ever find the None Piece?
what the slop are you watching
Yeah, it actually is pretty good. Never watched much of the anime, but I'm liking the characters a lot.
tell me which one is your favorite, depending on your answer I can guess if you are white and straight
Sanji
you are indian and brown
Stop gatekeeping live action anime.
Nojiko
You are white
Zoro
When will these morons shilling this trash frick off? It's been weeks by now.
You lost.
Hi Critical Drinker
Hi Mauler
Reminder that drinking isn't a personality.
When you stop seething
Yamato will never join. Cope and seethe.
>threads popping up left and right
>SHILLS SHILLS SHILLS
>threads start dying down
>LOLOL THE SHILLS HAVE GIVEN UP
one piece fans are mentally ill
If you're 12 and under I can maybe understand, if your older than that yeah you're a pillow biter
Haven’t seen it, looks like Netflix slop though. How the hell are they gonna afford literally anything after East Blue without it just looking like complete garbage? Skypia alone is gonna need like the budget of multiple marvel movies to look even ok, and I can’t even imagine how they’re gonna handle Water 7 or anything after that.
I'm scratching my head how Skypiea would be THAT expensive. Plus they can always change scope. Almost the entire second episode took place in a giant tent, instead of Buggy destroying a town. And it fricking worked.
>'m scratching my head how Skypiea would be THAT expensive
VFX are super expensive, majority of the budget of S1 went into CG for the fights, now imagine an arc where the fights are even crazier and the environment itself is also crazier.
Smoke machine plus Aztec props in a jungle. One set for angel island one set for upper yard. Enels final fight takes place on a boat. Not too out of the question
>Smoke machine
morons keep saying this without thinking that there's not a smoke machine big enough in the world to generate the amount necessary, so they will still need CG for the White Sea, and that they'll have to walk on solid clouds as well, which can't be done with a smoke machine because smoke ain't solid, so even more CG
>you just can’t put mist over water or the ground
Yeah you can though.
And it will look like shit, in order to make it look at least decent you'll need CG, and reminder that this is just the environment
I’m sure they’ll use CGI but you’re talking about in-universe prop wings and antennae, a few guys in coats with angel wings, and a white Detroiter. It really doesn’t seem that out of line at all
>Next up
Dragonball Z
It's genuinely bad in every way, costumes, story composition, writing, dialogues, cinematagrophy, score, pacing, cast outside of Sanji (ignoring that he's too big), Usopp and Nami
Genuinely just trash
Is it still kinda entertaining? Yeah because it's impossible to take an entire One Piece arc and put it in one or two episodes without it being entertaining. If you believe midly entertaining is what One Piece deserves, then go ahead and hype this trash
>do this shit but then somehow Sanji having a curly eyebrow would be "too ridiculous"
Definitely morons working on this one
>deserves
You say this like it hurts to have this in any way. We got this during a time when Oda was going on repeated breaks and still is, mind you. I don't enjoy every One Piece arc and I certainly don't enjoy all these breaks he keeps going on.
>You say this like it hurts to have this in any way.
The good ratings will encourage other Hollywood producers to make more shitty live action remakes (most of which won't include the contribution of the original writers) that won't do anything other than harm the image of the franchise and pander to morons who get filtered by the original because it's 2D.
Not to mention homosexuals like OP will keep plaguing places like this one by shilling this slop for free.
>The good ratings will encourage other Hollywood producers to make more shitty live action remakes
Which will be bad because...?
>that won't do anything other than harm the image of the franchise
Why the frick do you care what normies think about the franchise? I thought you didn't want any normies into the series.
>pander to morons who get filtered by the original because it's 2D.
Why do you care if they're only watching the live action instead of the original?
>Not to mention homosexuals like OP will keep plaguing places like this one by shilling this slop for free.
You're telling me you'd rather threads upon threads of Bane and Sneed posting instead of threads like this?
The show isn't great and is being massively astroturfed everywhere by shills but why are you pretending that the original is some masterpiece when it is just some dumb kids show.
What don't you like about the score? It's legitimately one of my favorites in a TV show in a long time.
that costume looks kinda good ngl
>tranimetard tries to critique actual kino
cringe
Yep yep YEP. When this moment happened, I PROUDLY and AUDIBLY yelled, "KIIIIINOOOOOO." And woke my aging, disappointed parents.
How do you pronounce his name? Is it Luffy or Loofy?
Loofy. And "Monkey" is his last name.
He's made of rubber.
How did that happen?
he ate some demon candy called gum gum
roofie
Luh-fee
Rough-E, out of respect to my fawtha and the Japanese creator
I liked it too anon.
>arab, nig, 56%, somebodies grandma and an asian
How was this different from any other Netflix show?
Do you want to know what's really kino? Nami.
Emily Rudd is kino. Nami is autism bait.
Biggest surprise of the year so far
How tf did they pull it off ?
This actor absolutely nailed Buggy. To the point that the anime version is complete shit now
Honestly, I think most people who've tried to adapt manga and anime properties just overthink it.
All the One Piece people did was have faith that what works in the source material will still work in live action and consult the original author. There wasn't anyone going "We need to make it more like Guardians of the Galaxy to make it work!" Like they did for Bebop. They had something that was already popular and did their best adapt it into a different format.
All the behind the scenes vids constantly mention the manga and not the anime. I think this is crucial to adapt this shit correctly. Use the manga source material not the anime
you dont know what youre talking about kid. this is on the same level as japanese anime/manga adaptions, i'd say even worse just for the amount of background Blacks, which is not faithful
I wouldn't go that far.
But it was solidly competent. A step above - several steps - any other anime adaptation I've seen. No Overtaken is a crime. What the frick, it ruined the entire scene.
Better than Wano arc in the manga.
>Kino
Yes. And Luffy and Sanji and Zoro are relentlessly handsome.
If they do Skypiea and Nami wears this exact outfit only then will I shout KINO.
I’ll be happy with her and Vivi wearing these outfits next season.
What’s the circled insignia on unibrow’s jacket?
Spoilers
???
???
Don't get your hopes up
It's very brave how all the villains are white and all the heroes are diverse
Is this a bot post? The villain was literally a black thug crying about slavery.
It's very brave how you post into a thread about a show you didn't watch to make statements that aren't true.
Is this shit actually worth watching? I like pirates of the Caribbean
It is definitely worth a watch. I was surprised how kino the first episode was and just continued watching. Majority of the casting choices were so perfect
It's good. It's unpretentious and doesn't take it seriously, the kind of show you will want to watch after a day of hard work
It's PotC with superpowers and less witty dialogue.
It's not like Pirates of the Caribean at all, it's decent on it's own, but don't go in expecting a standard pirate story
in terms of tone it's a lot closer to marvel/nu-star wars movies than potc
I liked the first episode, but afterwards Luffy became a bit too broody especially towards the end of the season.
>protagonist is a brown guy going around acting superior to everybody because he wants to rape, loot and murder
Defend this.
FINNA BE KING OF THE PIRATES
He’s acting superior because a white guy taught him he doesn’t actually have to get violent all the time
AY YO PIRATES ARE GOOD BOYS THEY DIDN DU NOTIN THEY JUST NEED MORE PIECES OF EIGHT FOR THIER PROGRAMS
In the OP world you get branded a criminal for running the jolly roger, regardless of whether or not you committed any crime. Luffy could have avoided a lot of trouble if he
>never once had a jolly roger, just called himself a sailor or trader
>handed any of his defeated enemies to the WG as bounties
>because he wants to rape, loot and murder
He's a different kind of pirate. He's a "pirate" for the adventure and freedom.
>listen to my headings luffy
>stay out of the reefs
>YOU WILL BREAK THE PIRATE SHIP LUFFY
>shut up
why did they do this
It will only be kino once we get Hanwiener simping on Luffy
Is this real
She will give you any endorsement with the right amount of fried chicken
https://twitter.com/YapapaMirage/status/1706434209038934402
Reading the reviews on imdb
>"Never watched anime in my life"
>but
>this is the best thing ever and totally better than cowboy bebop and I will proceed to watch the anime too
Truly a 25iq brownoid show for trannies. Kys shill.
First time watching this, and I'm liking it so far. 8/10.
No, not even close.
No one's talking about this anywhere.
I am
>No one's talking about this anywhere
>Oh besides the most-viewed news and talk program in daytime television with millions of viewers daily
STOP ENJOYING THINGS REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
I know it’s a kids show but it makes 0 sense for him to call himself a pirate. He never actually does pirate shit, ever. The only reason he’s wanted is because he runs around telling everyone he’s a criminal
See:
It's a problem that's never really addressed in the manga too. Hell, Whitebeard never hurts civilians or attacks marines. By all accounts, he shouldn't be wanted by the WG either.
It's just a setting. It literally could've been a western, and Luffy would've call himself a cowboy, without actually doing any herding
In Wanted, Oda’s cowboy story from before One Piece, the main character was just some guy who was considered a cowboy and the greatest gunman in the world just because he keeps beating people who challenge him because he’s got a poster for beating people for challenging him etc
Let me guess: actual deaths in these gun duels were about as common as One Piece?
Nah in the one shot a guy gets shot and follows around the main character as a ghost
Could make for an interesting premise then, I’ll have to check it out sometime.
He literally gets into fights with the marines and raids marine bases, what are you even talking about? The first thing he does is knock over a marine base, he gets his bounty for fighting the marines of Cocoyashi village, and the real concern of the bounty system and the world government is not to prevent crime, but to prevent people reaching Laugh Tale. The world government has basically outlawed free exploration anyways so adventuring does pretty much make you a pirate. And then besides Smoker they’re pursued by no one in the government until Water 7 because they literally declare open war against the WG. God you’re stupid
>the real concern of the bounty system and the world government is not to prevent crime, but to prevent people reaching Laugh Tale
Never explained or even hinted in the series. Go frick yourself for defending this shit. I could come up with dozens of examples of pirates in the series who were NEVER confirmed to have scuffled with the marines or WG or anything and they still had huge wanted posters.
How about Smoker’s entire stated motivation of keeping pirates out of the grand line? How about the dozens of times it’s been discussed research into the void century is punishable by death, and the government controlling the seas so they can hide a secret that will destroy them? This all besides the fact that, again, they had raided marine bases and assaulted marine captains before
Read my post entirely next time before responding. Even IF you agree Luffy deserves his bounty, dozens of other pirates don't. Free sailing on the grand line was never, ever stated to be a crime. Many "pirates" could have called themselves traders.
>uh wait a minute I…I only meant other pirates which I can name but won’t
Go ahead and name them. Luffy has a bounty from assaulting marine bases and marines, and the story reveals as it goes on that the government is primarily concerned with preventing travel towards the One Piece and discovery of the history of the void century which will destroy the world government
>the story reveals as it goes on that the government is primarily concerned with preventing travel towards the One Piece and discovery of the history of the void century which will destroy the world government
No, frick you, the series never hinted the 2 are linked at ALL.
The government magically puts a bounty on anyone who has a black jolly roger flag. Deal with it.
Whitebeard literally calls Sengoku and the government out over this with his dying words, that they’re scared of piracy because it leads to the one piece being found, which will start a catastrophic war and turn the world upside down. The Gorosei say the same thing later
Hell yeah
Not watching it
It convinced me to go watch the anime, I liked it. Buggy and Sanji are the best characters
Buggy is based and incredibly important to the whole story
Good, I'm glad he won't disappear after S1, they surely know how popular he was and have to keep him in a larger role
He kinda disappears from the story after East Blue and doesn't really do much again until Impel Down, so I'm guessing the writers are gonna change things a lot next season to keep Buggy relevant to the story
>kino
just end the series at the timeskip before it derails into pirateball z
oh no
Its over
full cgi would have looked trash not to mention expensive asf
>Sneedman
>Henson-style puppetry
It's gonna be so kino
Incoming
>same idea as Fishmen means just a kid with antlers on
The fishmen where way more complex and detailed a make up job than Sweet Tooth kid. If anything this further points towards a midget in a fursuit.
i hope its a cute shota i can self insert with
>here's your Brook, bro!
Will this series stretch out the in-universe timeline, with the journey through Paradise taking place over years instead of months? Don't see how they could otherwise explain the aging of the cast.
They won’t have to talk about it, just like they barely talk about the timeline in the manga. Sure you’ve got your time skip but it’s just media it goes along not really on a real calendar. They’ll be fine just not saying anything
The acting is so bad. Worse than the CW. I got half way through it and just couldn't anymore.
https://twitter.com/Truejustice_7/status/1704143052154061134
first look at S2 chopper
I've been way out of the loop. Please please please please tell me this isn't real.
I'm sorry, anon.
It’s good
All the villains did pretty good jobs with their roles.
Even Nezumi.
Uh oh