It's not "appealing to authority" it's the core of the argument.
The only thing that makes art objectively good is whether a large number of people like.
If majority of people like it but one person doesn't like it then it's objectively good.
Any other metric or criteria for a qualitative analysis of any work of art is completely subjective.
You don't understand anon. That poster has a literal god complex. He thinks he's more important, more moral and more intelligent than the everyone else that likes the artwork.
yea but the thing is, most people would hate Mulholland drive. if you showed it to 100 random normies, 90 would say it's dog shit. does that make it objectively bad? or would you say "well it's not made for them"?
3 months ago
Anonymous
You're thinking of 2001: Odyssey. Most normies would just say "That was a weird movie...I guess it was interesting though."
3 months ago
Anonymous
out of 100 random Western normies majority would still like it, hence why all the user-based ratings still show 70-90% approval
but I agree, when judging the reception of any art, the opinion of those who are actually into that medium should matter more (ie. cinephiles)
3 months ago
Anonymous
the opinion of those that are able to articulate a reason why something is good or bad instead of canned lines is who should be taken seriously, redditor. often times i'll notice the negative reviews for popular thing are more insightful than the good reviews which generally say nothing
3 months ago
Anonymous
>able to articulate a reason why something is good or bad instead of canned lines >"THIS UNIVERSALLY ACCLAIMED CLASSIC SUCKS BECAUSE IT'S LE REDDIT"
very insightful
3 months ago
Anonymous
argumentum ad populum and a strawman wowee
you finished, redditor?
3 months ago
Anonymous
no. normies would stop watching. they wouldn't bother to post on imdb, and they probably wouldn't bother to watch a movie older than 10 years.
Left always wins. Who the frick thinks about Slumdog Millionaire anymore.
Every year we get some shit movie that wins a million awards and is soon forgotten.
That was Camilla's reanimated corpse. It is not who Dan the eyebrow man was talking about. He was talking about the midget. Her corpse lives where the hit-and-run left the blue key for Diane to secretly communicate the murder was done. Camilla's corpse is guarding both the truth of what happened and her personal justice aka her future stolen. Her and Adam are the old people.
The first hour at least follows extremely strict rules that literally everything is from the direct observation and perspective of Rita not Betty. That's a big part of understanding this movie. Diane falls asleep and dreams she's Rita not Betty.
the great debate of our time
The left option.
>whats in my head is the objective reality, the world is just wrong
troony mentality
You hate it? Then you hate the premise of Mulholland Drive.
>appealing to authority for an opinion is objective reality
>My head cannon is all that matters. Nothing else.
Let me guess, you don't have any friends.
It's not "appealing to authority" it's the core of the argument.
The only thing that makes art objectively good is whether a large number of people like.
If majority of people like it but one person doesn't like it then it's objectively good.
Any other metric or criteria for a qualitative analysis of any work of art is completely subjective.
You don't understand anon. That poster has a literal god complex. He thinks he's more important, more moral and more intelligent than the everyone else that likes the artwork.
yea but the thing is, most people would hate Mulholland drive. if you showed it to 100 random normies, 90 would say it's dog shit. does that make it objectively bad? or would you say "well it's not made for them"?
You're thinking of 2001: Odyssey. Most normies would just say "That was a weird movie...I guess it was interesting though."
out of 100 random Western normies majority would still like it, hence why all the user-based ratings still show 70-90% approval
but I agree, when judging the reception of any art, the opinion of those who are actually into that medium should matter more (ie. cinephiles)
the opinion of those that are able to articulate a reason why something is good or bad instead of canned lines is who should be taken seriously, redditor. often times i'll notice the negative reviews for popular thing are more insightful than the good reviews which generally say nothing
>able to articulate a reason why something is good or bad instead of canned lines
>"THIS UNIVERSALLY ACCLAIMED CLASSIC SUCKS BECAUSE IT'S LE REDDIT"
very insightful
argumentum ad populum and a strawman wowee
you finished, redditor?
no. normies would stop watching. they wouldn't bother to post on imdb, and they probably wouldn't bother to watch a movie older than 10 years.
this post reeks of reddit. show us your funko pop collection, homosexualron
never posted on reddit in my life, no idea wtf a funko pop is. I do like Bootsy Collins
you're a redditor, you're playing stupid, you're fooling no one
seething redditor
>appeal to popularity
bahhhh
bahhhh
Your criteria is also subjective, brainlet.
>Hurry durr THEY LIKE IT
That's not what objective means.
Left always wins. Who the frick thinks about Slumdog Millionaire anymore.
Every year we get some shit movie that wins a million awards and is soon forgotten.
best movie
i found the first half interesting and everything afterwards just confusing and annoying.
The ending is scarier than the diner. Just utter hopelessness and terror.
What did the hobodemon represent? Was he like some sort of avatar of broken dreams?
no that was just the neighborhood witch
That was Camilla's reanimated corpse. It is not who Dan the eyebrow man was talking about. He was talking about the midget. Her corpse lives where the hit-and-run left the blue key for Diane to secretly communicate the murder was done. Camilla's corpse is guarding both the truth of what happened and her personal justice aka her future stolen. Her and Adam are the old people.
The first hour at least follows extremely strict rules that literally everything is from the direct observation and perspective of Rita not Betty. That's a big part of understanding this movie. Diane falls asleep and dreams she's Rita not Betty.
*the hitman left
Motherfricking autocorrect just tried to do it again to. They don't want us talking about hitmen.
Autocorrect is demoralization psyop
>b-but the keyboard is too small
So make it bigger.
Filtered. Simple as.
at least it tried. you've never tried to do anything.
Lost Highway and FWWM are so much better.