>wasn't followed to the letter,
The movie makers willfully misinterpreted the themes and plot of the book. Almost to the point where it breaks the overall story.
>that's just b***hing for the sake of b***hing
The book plot = good
the movie plot = bad.
>Cinemaphile homosexual jerks off Frank Herbert's dead dick for the umpteenth time as he screams "NEW BAD OLD GOOD!"
Nice knowing that nothing unique and interesting can be done, instead sticking to bullshit and leaving in worthless contrivances and fluff
2 weeks ago
Anonymous
lmao if you hate everything why are you even in this thread?
2 weeks ago
Anonymous
Because I like occasionally making fun of the rejects on here
2 weeks ago
Anonymous
Yeah, you're not better than the rest of us. In fact, you're an even bigger prick cause of the way you're acting.
2 weeks ago
Anonymous
>gay is whining because his clinginess to media is being mocked
I thought this was Cinemaphile you fricking pussy
That's weird because one of your main shilling points was its 100% true to the books
now that this slops marketing is over books are for homosexuals? I'll keep that in mind when you crawl to the /film/ board when the next one is released and try and pretend you have taste 🙂
Visuals and sound are superb and they could already give the movie the Oscars for visual effects/sound design bc it'll have-nots competitors. Perhaps cinematography too.
The story itself is unengaging bc it's the old/tired le obvious white nazis vs le tribal good savages (conflating palestines/"freedom fighters"/jews etc).
It's also a sexless movie, Pugh/Lea/Zendaya should have had at least one nude scene each.
Finally, the motivations are sometimes unclear.
I just pointed out how that term doesn't apply because they're willingly being led to committing genocide by someone who told them a useful lie for his own means, you mentally-castrated homosexual
It does apply you ignorant moron. Good savages are not devoid of savagery, their actions are rationalized bc they're depicted as "pure" and "justified"
They're not rationalized, they're blindly following a literal false prophet from an implanted mythos. That's why Paul is pissing himself over going through with it half the movie because he doesn't like how people will kill and die in his name against his wishes. They're also just scummy tribals in a backwater shithole known for its one valuable export
2 weeks ago
Anonymous
They're shown as following a "prophet" (or simply a leader for some of them) who'll facilitate their geopolitical/territorial claims and freedom from Harkonnen oppression. But they're clearly barbaric compared to the highly advanced Harkonnen culture.
2 weeks ago
Anonymous
Also none of the deaths would happen if Atreides never went to Arrakis.
2 weeks ago
Anonymous
They would've been genocided/driven to the fringes eventually by a more talented ruler
2 weeks ago
Anonymous
They're all following him now because he's a literal Messiah to them, they'll do basically whatever he wants them to do or die in his name voluntarily. Also there's no motive for Paul to do so since he too needs the spice to facilitate space travel unless he finds some way around it
Mediocre for the most part, with a few memorable scenes throughout. Best parts were the aesthetics of buildings, spacecraft and machines.
Inferior to the 80s version in storytelling, character design and acting.
I don't regret watching both in the cinema, I don't think I'll bother with a continuation or watching them again at home.
Suddenly the guild navigators (the dudes that can actually achieve interstellar travel) are carting off crazed jihadis that do not have the support of the great houses or the empire, when instead they could've just bombarded them from space indefinitely.
>but them nukes hitting the spice depots
don't tell me it's impossible to simply bombard the planet then land and continue spice harvesting. they're all in one place, FRICK them up then continue as normal without the slave/jihadi population. obviously genocide is not an issue in this universe.
I don't like it. There's a humanness to the book that is severely lacking in Denis adaption. The art direction could've been more naturalistic too. Denis can't give acting directions for shit. Timothy is a trainwreck choice for Paul, and way worse than Zendaya as Chani. Zendaya is bad because of what they chose to do with the character, but with the right direction she could've been passable.
Really good, but not amazing. It seems Denis will forever be capped out at making 8/10s, never truly achieving greatness.
Chani was miscast
She had white girl hair in part 1 but black girl hair in part 2
Great movie but holy shit did they rape the book plot. They could fix it in Dune 3 but I know they won't.
Who fricking cares? Books are for homosexuals
>Books are for homosexuals
>Without the book there'd be no movie
pick one.
It's not binary, you actual moron. Just because your gay little book wasn't followed to the letter, that's just b***hing for the sake of b***hing
>your gay little book
>great movie
pick one
>wasn't followed to the letter,
The movie makers willfully misinterpreted the themes and plot of the book. Almost to the point where it breaks the overall story.
>that's just b***hing for the sake of b***hing
The book plot = good
the movie plot = bad.
>Cinemaphile homosexual jerks off Frank Herbert's dead dick for the umpteenth time as he screams "NEW BAD OLD GOOD!"
Nice knowing that nothing unique and interesting can be done, instead sticking to bullshit and leaving in worthless contrivances and fluff
lmao if you hate everything why are you even in this thread?
Because I like occasionally making fun of the rejects on here
Yeah, you're not better than the rest of us. In fact, you're an even bigger prick cause of the way you're acting.
>gay is whining because his clinginess to media is being mocked
I thought this was Cinemaphile you fricking pussy
That's weird because one of your main shilling points was its 100% true to the books
now that this slops marketing is over books are for homosexuals? I'll keep that in mind when you crawl to the /film/ board when the next one is released and try and pretend you have taste 🙂
I like all sand movies. 5/10 average sand movie.
Visuals and sound are superb and they could already give the movie the Oscars for visual effects/sound design bc it'll have-nots competitors. Perhaps cinematography too.
The story itself is unengaging bc it's the old/tired le obvious white nazis vs le tribal good savages (conflating palestines/"freedom fighters"/jews etc).
It's also a sexless movie, Pugh/Lea/Zendaya should have had at least one nude scene each.
Finally, the motivations are sometimes unclear.
>good savages
>literal blind fanatics with misplaced faith who are about to go do jihad
You fricking moronic or something?
No, but you are bc you're obviously a midwit who doesn't know about the "good savage" concept. Educate yourself Timmy
I just pointed out how that term doesn't apply because they're willingly being led to committing genocide by someone who told them a useful lie for his own means, you mentally-castrated homosexual
It does apply you ignorant moron. Good savages are not devoid of savagery, their actions are rationalized bc they're depicted as "pure" and "justified"
They're not rationalized, they're blindly following a literal false prophet from an implanted mythos. That's why Paul is pissing himself over going through with it half the movie because he doesn't like how people will kill and die in his name against his wishes. They're also just scummy tribals in a backwater shithole known for its one valuable export
They're shown as following a "prophet" (or simply a leader for some of them) who'll facilitate their geopolitical/territorial claims and freedom from Harkonnen oppression. But they're clearly barbaric compared to the highly advanced Harkonnen culture.
Also none of the deaths would happen if Atreides never went to Arrakis.
They would've been genocided/driven to the fringes eventually by a more talented ruler
They're all following him now because he's a literal Messiah to them, they'll do basically whatever he wants them to do or die in his name voluntarily. Also there's no motive for Paul to do so since he too needs the spice to facilitate space travel unless he finds some way around it
Mid. I'm halfway through the second book and it's a way better story.
Redeemed Lynch + TV series, outside of the worm riding POV
Nice bait, homosexual
I liked the spice mommy
My wife liked when spice mommy talked to the baby
Mediocre for the most part, with a few memorable scenes throughout. Best parts were the aesthetics of buildings, spacecraft and machines.
Inferior to the 80s version in storytelling, character design and acting.
I don't regret watching both in the cinema, I don't think I'll bother with a continuation or watching them again at home.
Suddenly the guild navigators (the dudes that can actually achieve interstellar travel) are carting off crazed jihadis that do not have the support of the great houses or the empire, when instead they could've just bombarded them from space indefinitely.
>but them nukes hitting the spice depots
don't tell me it's impossible to simply bombard the planet then land and continue spice harvesting. they're all in one place, FRICK them up then continue as normal without the slave/jihadi population. obviously genocide is not an issue in this universe.
I watched 5h of this and I couldn't tell a thing appart from
>le Lisan Algaib
What a fricking scam
I don't like it. There's a humanness to the book that is severely lacking in Denis adaption. The art direction could've been more naturalistic too. Denis can't give acting directions for shit. Timothy is a trainwreck choice for Paul, and way worse than Zendaya as Chani. Zendaya is bad because of what they chose to do with the character, but with the right direction she could've been passable.
I'm glad someone is finally calling out timothy for his weak performance. He's currently coasting on the glaring failure of his costars.
Seeing him trying to be intimidating and commanding was embarrassing.
He literally stomped his foot, like an angry toddler.
It looks pretty bad but I might’ve watched it if there were less black people in it.