the frick

Classic serial killer psychology. He raped his daughter then immortalized it in the form of Twin Peaks to satiate his fricked up psyche. The daughter was totally candid in her defense and not compelled at all to write out a half baked defense under threats from her psycho dad

film is not a narrative medium and plot doesn't matter
turn off the frankenstein controls, schizo; they're making you a plebeian

Not an argument.

I bet there is a companion snuff film that lynch directed. He seems like that kinda guy.

>If you simply shrug off violent CP as a nothingburger then might as well report yourself to your local nuthouse before the neighbourhood children go missing.
Its about a disturbing subject matter. Why wouldn't he use disturbing imagery and a warped narrative to showcase it?

The entire point is the mandane father/daughter relationship being distorted, defiled and destroyed. Hence Lynch mixes banal, ordinary imagry with the abstract and perverse. We the viewer get to see the distorted evil that is lurking in a familiar mundane place.

If you were unsettled and disturbed watching it, then good. Thats the point of the movie.

Its art that made me feel something. That automatically makes it kino.

also in guess my mental is strong enough to not get twisted up by a work of fictikn. I guess im just built different.

>none of it adds anything from a storytelling perspective at all.
It's about showing how Laura has been corrupted but chooses to sacrifice herself instead of continuing the cycle of abuse.

>Again, we already got that from the TV show, infact it was outright stated. So why do we need an entire hour of visual documentation? How does it add anything at all? Are you implying that the information that a father raped and murdered his daughter isn't disturbing on its own, and needs visual documentation to accompany it?
Why make movies at all? If pure information is all that matters they we could just write the plot synopsis for stories, since apparently presentation and artisric exploration is a waste of time and triggers skitzos

I like to feel things that are outside of my normal range of emotions. Art lets you do so in a safe and interesting way. I watched the movie, felt a little weird, a little sad and a little angry. Then i moved along with my life.

People who cant separate fiction from their real experiences are mentally unbalanced. Thats just how it is.

if you think lynch advocates for pedo snuff IRL, do you also think christopher nolan goes out and beats up criminals dressed as batman? No he doesnt. Its just a move.

>oh no a bad man did something on the televison and now I can't differentiate right from wrong
Really? Grow up.

Watching disturbing movies doesn't affect your moral compass if your over the age of 5 or not mentally ill.

Theres my argument

buzzwords that have no relevance because you can't refute my point.

Watching disturbing movies doesn't affect your moral compass if your over the age of 5 or not mentally ill.

Theres my argument

Not the point I'm making, but okay. Remain ignorant, it's the last refuge you have. I understand I used to be like you, but then I saw the strings and the people who get to pull them.

You moved to another buzzword after I mocked you. You're batting a thousand, champ. That's short for champion.

Wow what a cargo cult.

You're playing T-ball against babe ruthless right now buddy, and honey we're going down swinging.

>cares more about winning than being a good person.
I'll pray for you friend.

What is your point then?
>the film is unnecessary
its art. If it was necessary then it wouldn't be art
>its disturbing/dark/morbid
Yes thats the major theme of the movie
>It displays things that I think should not be displayed
Cool. Your opinion is yours though. Other people should be allowed to decide for for themselves.
>lynch is a bad person
never met the dude. art=/= the artist though
>its CP and snuff
its a movie. Nobody got hurt in real life.
>its different from twin peaks
ok and?
>it will make you evil if you watch it
No problem ill just watch 90 mins of wholesome christian cartoons to balance it out...

Sorry i didnt realise it wasnt you. Things get complicated when your talking to people with multiple voices in their head...

Ill wear that one. Actually made me laugh

>ptsd from a movie

The point of movies is story telling. What story did this "movie" tell? We already know what the girl went through, all of her life is already spealt out in the 2 seasons, so what's the point of making the most egregious perverse piece of visual medium possible on already established information instead of progressing the plot? Why is this movie so jarringly out of sync with the more quirky tone of the TV shows? It doesn't fit in at all? What possible themes do 10 minutes of a minor being BDSM raped by strangers while high on drugs, and then further kidnapped raped and murdered by her own father spell out that wasn't already mentioned in the TV show? This is sick, and the fact that it was allowed to air implies a deeper conspiracy at foot.

>The town is seemingly a quaint nice place , an ideal, peaceful place where people are good and nice to eachother. But as things progress more darker secrets and truths are revealed. In real life

Yes, all of this is already established by episode 5 of season 1. We are already told of drugs being smuggled and peddled to kids in high school, we're told of the active prostitution ring under the control of the town's most powerful business man, we're told of secret affairs and underlying criminal conspiracies virtually every single episode in both the seasons. The towns depiction as a quiet peaceful and simple place is already debunked as a misleading mirage by the end of season 1, and season 2 goes even further with it. The "movie" on the other hand adds nothing at all to this narrative, instead just distastefully depicting the harrowing events in the most crude and borderline illegal manner possible. It's just a 2 hour long shock video at this point, and transcends from being eerily unsettling to downright outrageous. It feels like the freak in charge wasn't satisfied with merely Establishing a horrendous crime through storytelling, he had to go 10 steps further and actually depict it on screen. We know child rape is evil, do we really need to see it for ourselves to hammer in a point every single human already implicitly understands to the the fullest.

I researched more about the TV show and turns out Lych was intermittently involved woth the series, fricking off periodically to work on other distressing media no doubt. It seems he wasn't merely satisfied with artfully depicting a heinous crime, he felt compelled to actually direct it, for reasons discernible only to him.

The movie is a borderline snuff film no 2 ways about it, it's rotten to the very core

This is cope lol. The protag is literally an FBI agent, and Lynch himself stars as the le wholesome chungus FBI boss. Also the military intelligence guy from the show is portrayed as this wise mystic dude. Lynch is 100% in bed with intelligence agencies

So he traumatizes you and then you love it. Hmm so he takes you and traumatizes you... trauma. Yeah the schizos right.

We already got that through character interactions in the TV series, it is something heavily insinuated and even directly implied on multiple occasions, it absolutely didn't need to be codified on film in the most unsettling manner possible.

[...]
>The entire point is the mandane father/daughter relationship being distorted, defiled and destroyed

Again, we already got that from the TV show, infact it was outright stated. So why do we need an entire hour of visual documentation? How does it add anything at all? Are you implying that the information that a father raped and murdered his daughter isn't disturbing on its own, and needs visual documentation to accompany it?

There needs to be HARD limits in what you can depict on film. Just because you can doesn't. Mean you should. This "movie" is perverse and a direct attack on humanity

>the women in their twenties are minors

You have to prove he did that first though
thx for admitting your error on the CP accusations

Cities full of bad people

Establishing that a character on film is most definitely a minor and then having all the perverse shit happen to her is indeed CP, the "reality" of it is immaterial. Theres a reason why depiction of kids getting murdered on film, despite it just being fiction, is banned, because it perverts the psyche.

[...]
>Hollywood is 70% snuff
I've seen Hollywood movies all my life, guess I missed out on the snuff. What is egregious is that the TV series, tho still being a bit weird and unsettling at times, is MUCH tamer than the movie, which is required viewing(despite adding absolutely nothing to the lore)to progress, it's like the freak intentionally used a bait and switch to blast his perversion brazenly and attempt to corrupt the viewers psyche.

>Establishing that a character on film is most definitely a minor and then having all the perverse shit happen to her is indeed CP
Um but it isn't doe cause dat's not what CP is

>So you admit you're not a good person then
I can't admit what's not true.

You've been forever altered too, you're just too simple minded to notice it

Well you apparently got conditioned by shit that Lynch basically threw together randomly. His interviews make it very clear that he comes up with elements and shots as he goes.

Even the character BOB was just a Set Manager who was accidently reflected in a mirror in a shot and Lynch thought it was cool so added him to the movie.

You're acting like its some level 9000 satanic cognitohazard when Lynch is like if a enthusiastic high school performing arts teacher was good at editing.

As if the freak would openly boast of deeds that could land him in extreme trouble, he knows what he did. Everybody who's seen that film is psychologically worse off, only select few have the self awareness and control over their mind to realize it.