This series feels so much like the prequels where people are constantly just sitting and talking about shit that isn't interesting at all. I was baffled when an entire scene was some rich buttholes sitting at breakfast talking about the important dinner party and what they were going to wear. Then you got other scenesbjust like it, just people sitting and talking about nothing.
 |
 |
|
(You)
How about a rebuttal, oh wait you can't, homosexual.
He’s not wrong. It’s boring, and you are a homosexual.
season 2 when
I freely admit I was rooting for the nicely-dressed people in the brightly lit room the entire time. Seeing the Imperial Gestapo from the inside was engrossing.
>Seeing the Imperial Gestapo from the inside was engrossing.
Yes, it's a good job it was in this show and not any of the other ones who'd have completely fricked it up
>Seeing the Imperial Gestapo from the inside was engrossing.
Mostly very good, but the scenes in episode 4 suffer from the same lack-of-sanity-checks problem as a lot of other content in Andor. The 'healthcare' speech the Major delivers is great, but the show, seemingly unintentionally, makes him a hypocrite later on in the same damn episode.
Consider that the Major takes Legrette to task for awaiting a recommendation from a regional ministerial director, because, (sarcastically), 'they've done such an excellent job so far,' and that 'we identify symptoms, we locate germs, whether they arise from within or have come from the outside; the longer we wait to identify a disorder, the harder it is to treat the disease.'
This stands entirely at odds with his determination against giving Dedra the data about the robbery, that they only act on 'vetted information', and also that she should confine future inquiries to her own sector. Furthermore Dedra should have, or at least would have, thrown his own metaphor back at him: how do you diagnose a disease when you are not being allowed to examine the patient?
Now, if the show had used acting and cinematography to give us the impression that Dedra *wanted* to say something like this but refrained (perhaps in anticipation that the Major was not in a mood to accept this dispassionately), then we'd have had something that rings true. Plenty of other directions to take that, too, like having the Major recognize what she's saying is true, but insisting that she complete her reports first as a higher-level responsibility, and also that she work jointly with Levin on a report about her supposed 'pattern', etc
With a script doctor identifying shit like this the show could've been really special
You missed the point of the imperial characters completely. Nice job.
no u, moron. the Major is shown to be highly intelligent and competent from the beginning, and also as amenable to change and caring primarily about results a couple episodes later, after Dedra sidestepped the rules and ignored his instructions. Again, this makes the initial hypocrisy, as presented, not in keeping with his character
He can't give free reign to every officer willy-nilly because he's a bureaucrat and he doesn't want people to potentially usurp him. When Dedra proves shes onto something, and is prepared and confidant enough to have a report ready, and he gets the opportunity to knock down Blevins he accepts it.
Yeah he is a hypocrite, part of the reason he agreed with Dedra early on was to take smug guy Blevins down a peg. He was probably sitting on the healthcare speech for ages just aching to have a chance to bust it out
> just people sitting and talking about nothing.
So nothing like the prequels then.
I think people are comparing this shit to the Mandalorian because nothing happens and a 40minute episode could be condensed to 10 minutes and lose nothing.
>about shit that isn't interesting at all
rong
It was probably a script for something else before they slapped the Star Wars IP on it.
I watch for hag-kino.
That being said: have a nice day, zoomer marvel-cuck.
The best shows in the world have people just talking for most scenes.
See: Deadwood, Fargo, Mr. Inbetween.
tv shows are literally made for dialogue
>someone says a movie is boring and has too much talking about nothing interesting
>YOU PROBABLY HATE THOSE MOVIES WHERE THEY TALKED ABOUT INTERESTING THINGS
Why are pseuds like this?
>Star Wars: Has exposition so we can understand the choices and thoughts of completely unknown alien cultures and/or some sort of tech
>GAAAAAY, JUST GET ON WITH THE STORY
>Nu-Star Wars: literal fricking plotholes everywhere and then a tweet, from one of the executives on the show/movie, 6 months after airing explaining some of the moronic background
>JUST EXPLAIN IT IN THE MOVIE GODDAMN IT
>the first good thing disney has done with Star Wars: Hey, let's explain these characters a little more for context
>AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH! WHY AM I WATCHING DRAMA UNFOLD AT A DINNER TABLE?!?!?!?!??!
Why are moronic mongoloid Black person israelites like this?
I thought the first two episodes were a little boring but the last 10 were great.
It's a good 8 episode story stretched over 12 episodes, and as a result we get 3 or 4 scenes showing that the Rebellion is putting a strain on Mon Mothma's family life or that Syril hates living with his mom when only 1 or 2 scenes would do. The acting and screenwriting is not really strong enough for it to be a truly character driven drama.
Isn't it the only good piece of Disney Wars media?
It is well written and exists to tell a story instead of sell toys that being said it is slow moving
I'm just happy dave filoni go the green light to assist on the story for season 2.
I puked a little in my mouth
counterargument: it's not boring and it's interesting
I bet your the type of same guy who rants about rey every time somebody mentions the sequel trilogy
Saw first half of episode 1 and never returned. Boring as shit. I'm tired of this DLC side quest C-list character background stuff.
Because the script is AI generated