He may be right but he definitely isn't smart as he is thought to be.
He could've just exited silently and then leaked the story , but he had to just show how he is morally superior to the team by telling them his plan to leak it.
He hated all of them except Night owl. He called Scarlet prostitute , Ozymandias a homosexual and dunno what he called Manhattan but certainly didn't hold him upto a high regard.
Even called Nite Owl some shit but considered him friend in the film atleast.
>He could've just exited silently and then leaked the story , but he had to just show how he is morally superior to the team by telling them his plan to leak it.
Are you moronic? His whole thing is being morally incorruptible. If he has to tell a lie to expose a lie that defeats the entire fricking point of that worldview. He would literally be doing the exact same thing he was lambasting Ozy about.
I mean it's bad how hateful he is towards people in general but his actions are pretty much always a good thing or deserved at least. If I was supposed to hate him why does he always do the morally correct thing?
Yes. In my personal opinion he wanted to be a hard man and fix the world in his own twisted way, but once given the opportunity to do so on a mass scale he couldn't handle making the hard decisions and hid like a coward behind a thin veil of moral righteousness.
>people who do wrong should get punished >people who dont do wrong shouldnt be punished >no you shouldnt kill millions of people indiscriminately because thats not the same thing as punishing wrongdoers
i dont see how hes a hypocrite at all. the comedian is who you seem to be describing and that plot point is spelled out in the movie
He was right. With a thought, Manhattan could've undone all the damage. Maybe even resurrected those people. Instead Manhattan decided to kill the one man with a conscious and then frick off while the world burned.
The Comedian was right. It's all a joke.
he was correct. manipulating people into peace is just as bad as manipulating them into war. he felt that if people weren't willing to save the world through their everyday actions, then they deserved to be doomed. he was a man who believed in cause and effect. and he believed in punishment for the people that deserved it. killing millions of innocent people so that many millions more that were not innocent could live was unacceptable in his eyes.
No but you gotta realize other people dont work on the same moral scale you live your life/exist by. Read the fricking room and try to exercise justice in your own way. He didnt have to do all that and could have lived to do more good now hes dead because he had to tell them how much more of a good person he was than just BEING a good by person by his actions you dont need to tell people your a good person if you really were that was just a ego boost which got him killed.
He was right, Adrian's idea was crazy and arrogant, and there is no guarantee it will work and no guarantee it was even necessary at all. I guess Rorshach at that point didn't have anything left to live for and no one on his side at all
Yes and it's incredible that he was written by a person who disagreed with him. I actually respect Moore as an author for displaying certain ideologies correctly, despite thinking that they're wrong.
holy shit, alan moore on suicide watch
He may be right but he definitely isn't smart as he is thought to be.
He could've just exited silently and then leaked the story , but he had to just show how he is morally superior to the team by telling them his plan to leak it.
He loved those people once. They were his friends. And they were just going along with it. He snapped.
He hated all of them except Night owl. He called Scarlet prostitute , Ozymandias a homosexual and dunno what he called Manhattan but certainly didn't hold him upto a high regard.
Even called Nite Owl some shit but considered him friend in the film atleast.
Definitely didn't love them.
he's like me but about the vaccine
>He loved those people once. They were his friends. And they were just going along with it.
he did leak the story
>he should have just betrayed all his morals for convince and to kowtow to gay pedo hitler!
how to say youre a leftist without saying youre a leftist
Are these real quotes? I can't find them.
why would you think that any political quotes on 4chin are real? sweet summer child.
>He could've just exited silently and then leaked the story , but he had to just show how he is morally superior to the team by telling them his plan to leak it.
Are you moronic? His whole thing is being morally incorruptible. If he has to tell a lie to expose a lie that defeats the entire fricking point of that worldview. He would literally be doing the exact same thing he was lambasting Ozy about.
I mean it's bad how hateful he is towards people in general but his actions are pretty much always a good thing or deserved at least. If I was supposed to hate him why does he always do the morally correct thing?
He was absolutely right.
What he was not, was realistic or nuanced.
Yes. In my personal opinion he wanted to be a hard man and fix the world in his own twisted way, but once given the opportunity to do so on a mass scale he couldn't handle making the hard decisions and hid like a coward behind a thin veil of moral righteousness.
>people who do wrong should get punished
>people who dont do wrong shouldnt be punished
>no you shouldnt kill millions of people indiscriminately because thats not the same thing as punishing wrongdoers
i dont see how hes a hypocrite at all. the comedian is who you seem to be describing and that plot point is spelled out in the movie
Legit no. Truth is truth and that cannot be compromised.
No, the truth always comes out and the longer a lie lasts, the more damage is caused by truth inevitably coming out.
He was right. With a thought, Manhattan could've undone all the damage. Maybe even resurrected those people. Instead Manhattan decided to kill the one man with a conscious and then frick off while the world burned.
The Comedian was right. It's all a joke.
He's wrong. People love hearing lies more than the truth.
he was correct. manipulating people into peace is just as bad as manipulating them into war. he felt that if people weren't willing to save the world through their everyday actions, then they deserved to be doomed. he was a man who believed in cause and effect. and he believed in punishment for the people that deserved it. killing millions of innocent people so that many millions more that were not innocent could live was unacceptable in his eyes.
i agree.
what about the millions of innocent people who would inevitably die because of the war? Stupid fricking logic.
No.
Yes, though he was based for killing all the scum.
No but you gotta realize other people dont work on the same moral scale you live your life/exist by. Read the fricking room and try to exercise justice in your own way. He didnt have to do all that and could have lived to do more good now hes dead because he had to tell them how much more of a good person he was than just BEING a good by person by his actions you dont need to tell people your a good person if you really were that was just a ego boost which got him killed.
In the Director’s Cut he obviously wasn’t perfect yet he still had a better moral compass than anyone on the team except Night Owl probably.
It's kinda like Manhattan said,
>"Without condoning or condemning, I understand."
The ginger man was very short sighted.
He was right, Adrian's idea was crazy and arrogant, and there is no guarantee it will work and no guarantee it was even necessary at all. I guess Rorshach at that point didn't have anything left to live for and no one on his side at all
Yes and it's incredible that he was written by a person who disagreed with him. I actually respect Moore as an author for displaying certain ideologies correctly, despite thinking that they're wrong.
Skip Bayless?