Have you actually read every one of these or are you just going off what you've seen other people say? Remember, time you spend arguing about comics is time that you could be spending reading comics.
>I'm going off of roughly Cinemaphile consensus
That makes no sense, at least not for comics, it's a bit easier to find a consensus on cartoons but almost every comic is divisive here.
Of that list? Yeah Calvin and Hobbes is the only comic there that you can recommend to both casuals and more strict critics and everybody will aknowledge it's great.
Have you actually read every one of these or are you just going off what you've seen other people say? Remember, time you spend arguing about comics is time that you could be spending reading comics.
Watchmen, Love and Rockets (specifically Human Diastrophism , The Death of Speedy, and The Love Bunglers), and Cerebus (specifically Jaka's Story and Minds) are S-tier. Asterios Polyp is another S-tier comic.
Persepolis is significantly less good than Maus.
what's persepolis about?
some biography about an islamic woman. it's a really boring and pretentious comic
I remember getting forced to read watchmen as a teen on HS
Doubt that would fly today cause of the penis and sex scenes
Why was it on your curriculum at all?
some richgay crying about an islamic regime that she initially supported until her uncle got executed
Have you actually read every one of these or are you just going off what you've seen other people say? Remember, time you spend arguing about comics is time that you could be spending reading comics.
I'm going off of roughly Cinemaphile consensus and how they're seen, that's how I'm putting it together. Just curious.
>I'm going off of roughly Cinemaphile consensus
That makes no sense, at least not for comics, it's a bit easier to find a consensus on cartoons but almost every comic is divisive here.
>Top tier: What I like
>Shit tier: What I don't like
tintin
asterix
lucky luke
koing
corto maltese
mortadelo y filemon
les smurfs
et le liste continue
Swap Maus and Persepolis with Hellboy and Bone and the list isn’t too bad
Calvin and Hobbes is unironically better than any of those "S-Tier" comics.
Calvin and Hobbes is the only REAL S tier.
Of that list? Yeah Calvin and Hobbes is the only comic there that you can recommend to both casuals and more strict critics and everybody will aknowledge it's great.
S tier:
- Scrooge McDuck
- Maus
- Scott Pilgrim
A Tier
- Calvin and Hobbes
- Hellboy
- Sandman
B tier
- Watchmen
C tier
- Dark Knight Returns
D tier:
- Ultimate Spider-Man
- Killing Joke
Never read it:
- Miller's Daredevil
- Bone
- Eightball
- Cerebus
- Love and Rockets
- Persepolis
At least you're honest.
Read more besides capeshit
>Scott Pilgrim
Why? So someone can give you (You)s on how lazy your bait is? Is that it? Ok then, here is your (You) you're welcome.
Cerebus is in a tier of its own.
Watchmen, Love and Rockets (specifically Human Diastrophism , The Death of Speedy, and The Love Bunglers), and Cerebus (specifically Jaka's Story and Minds) are S-tier. Asterios Polyp is another S-tier comic.
Persepolis is significantly less good than Maus.
Maus is shit. So sick of people saying it’s great when it’s not
Maus is great. So sick of people saying it’s shit when it’s not