Which one do you prefer? If there will ever be a remake, would you prefer actors who look closer to the books descriptions?
 Shopping Cart Returner Shirt $21.68 |
 Tip Your Landlord Shirt $21.68 |
Shopping Cart Returner Shirt $21.68 |
Which one do you prefer?
Watson was fine in the first two if a little overacting, she was dire from then on and just played herself. Like she does in everything.
face doesn't really matter when you're eating her out
Hermione is black, Rowling confirmed it. Neither of those images are accurate.
>Emma Charlotte Duerre Watson[7] was born on 15 April 1990 in Paris, to English lawyers Chris Watson and Jacqueline Luesby.[8][9][10][11] Watson lived in Maisons-Laffitte near Paris until age five. Her parents divorced when she was young, and Watson moved to England to live with her mother in Oxfordshire while spending weekends at her father's house in London.[9][12] Watson has said she speaks some French, though "not as well" as she used to.[13] After moving to Oxford with her mother and brother, she attended the Dragon School, remaining there until 2003.[9] From age six, she wanted to become an actress,[14] and trained at the Oxford branch of Stagecoach Theatre Arts, a part-time theatre school where she studied singing, dancing, and acting.[15]
She isn't israeli.
Disgusting.
I don't know, but now i wanna know how do they blush?
>She isn't israeli.
She should be black, thoughever.
The israeliteess on the right is going to look mighty ugly 3-4 years from now
That is a generated photo, which doesn't age.
can black people go white with shock?
I'm actually kind of shocked the TV remake isn't making any of the main three black.
She could have been referring to shock, fear, or any other emotion that would allow her to use 'white face' as a literary device. I don't think she specifies Dean Thomas' black face anywhere does she?
see
Rowling isn't taking a moment at this climactic point in the book to describe her skin color. She's "white in the face" due to intense emotion.
The problem Rowling is does mention if a character is black. Lee Jordan, Kingsley, etc, in their descriptions mention being black. If she had ever intended Hermione to be anything other than white English, she would have said it. Never mind that she had plenty of say in the movie adaptations that characters had to stay British and Irish, and be cast close to their book counterparts. They aren't 1:1 (Radcliffe has blue eyes rather than green, and wound up being short rather than tall though that's out of their control, for instance), but they are close.
>If she had ever intended Hermione to be anything other than white English, she would have said it.
Yet she is saying it now.
she capitulated to some idiots in New York casting that stupid play. dancing around the question because it was always implicit that hermione was a white brit, so she didn't spell it out in the books.
you don't describe black hair as bushy unless you're being racist btw.
And she made it up to justify that one play casting a black actress as Hermione, which was actually done because colorblind casting in theater is normal and has been done for decades.
is that how you would phrase it for black people though?
i guess that is kind of a tough question since all good writing has been done by white people about white people
You wouldn't describe blacks as blushing or having a flushed face either.
Black's can blush but their faces don't turn pale when they're shocked. The real question is if they can talk until they're blue in the face
hermione stared, her mouth hung loosely slightly more than usual
Frick off with this disingenuous revisionism.
It's right there in the book, not disingenuous nor is it revisionism. Especially since Rowling has outright said that Hermione can be black and she never described her skin color. Doing stuff like pulling out some quickly drawn concept art to try and prove that wrong is disingenuous.
i notice you keep ignoring my other replies where you get btfo
it was obvious that hermione was white based on the context of the story. in the 90s it wasn't considered racist to not shoehorn every other race into your book.
It may not have been considered racist but it was still racist.
good
>it was obvious that hermione was white based on the context of the story. in the 90s it wasn't considered racist to not shoehorn every other race into your book.
Rowling has stated that Hermione can be any race and the vagueness around her skin color in the books confirms this. It's your word versus the actual author's.
lmao so she was imagining some racially ambiguous girl as her self-insert?
using the words "can be" is obviously just kid-glove speak so as to not make a moron cry.
According to her, yes.
>she was being vague about it by using "can be" therefore she's actually white!
Lmao what a cope.
Maybe if they didn't have children. Rowling would probably state that she isn't, knowing her politics.
>Maybe if they didn't have children
It doesn't explicitly say that they don't adopt or use a surrogate so maybe that's what they did.
Troonism wasn't much of a thing in the 80s/90s, but I'm sure you could ask Rowling if she is transgender.
joanne is white, her self-insert is white
most brits (especially in the 80s and 90s) are white
i know you're just pretending to be moronic but this is somewhat cathartic because i know there are insane bluehairs who actually think like this
>her self insert is white
Maybe to you, as the creator she can do what she wants with the characters if it was something that wasn't outright stated.
she didn't even do it
She pretty clearly stated that Hermione can be any race.
she didn't write her as explicitly black
she wrote her as implicitly white
kek
>she wrote her as implicitly white
Show me texts from the book that prove this besides the white-faced thing (which doesn't count because it's used as a literary device)
if she were black describing her hair and eyes wouldn't make sense.
At one point in book 3 her face is described as so pale it is extremely visible even tough she's hiding in the middle of the woods, I don't care how scared a Black is, they can't get pale enough to be visible in the darkness of a forest at night, it's obvious Rowling didn't mean that she was pale out of fear, but that she's simply naturally pale.
>At one point in book 3 her face is described as so pale it is extremely visible even tough she's hiding in the middle of the woods
Already been addressed. Find a different example.
She comes from a two parent home.
>its doesn't say Hermione isn't trans so its possible that she is
The thing about it is that being black makes a bunch of plot beats really weird. Like all the mudblood stuff and house elf slavery thing. They literally shit on her and wonder why she even cares at all for the house elf thing.
It would come across a little weird. For Harry especially, knowing about how much blacks jerk off over their slave narrative.
Same with gay dumbledore taking an interest in young Harry Potter, coming to his office in the middle of the night and going on solo trips with him.
>If there will ever be a remake
Hopefully Hermione is a pretty mullatta with cute puffy hair.
Hermione is canonically brazilian
yo, they did my homie Gary dirty. replacing him with "Dean" like that.
Pedo
I've been re-reading the books lately and the idea that Hermoine is ugly is just fricking ridiculous
It's clear that Hermoine is at most an average girl who isn't obsessed with her appearance
She gets her teeth magically altered anyway
She was never described as ugly, just a normal girl with big teeth
They actually tried to give Watson false teeth for the first movie but they didn't work out. She's actually wearing them in the end scene at the train station.
Why did they give up on making her hair curly after the second movie?
That torture scene in the theater set my 12-year-old self down the path I now find myself on.
They're gonna negrify her.
Hermione will be black. The question is, will she be a mulatta or a straight up bantu? Knowing britbongs, it could go either way.
By the way, here's the image that apparently triggered the Cinemaphile mod. I'll make a point of posting it in every thread now.
if wizards can magic their poo away can they do the same with their melanin?
thats why blacks in harry potter is unrealistic, If lived in the wizarding world i know damn well i'd use magic to wish my black ass skin away and become a white man. My homie dobby better hook me up before he get a cap busted up his ass.
Acknowledging that Hermione was described as white is racism outside of /b/ you bigot!!