I also recall Tyrion being a lot more of an butthole in the books. If I recall correctly he just straight up kills her, in the show they change it to her attacking him first.
yep. in the book she calls him "my giant" which was something she said in court that everyone laughed at, and this triggers the frick out of him so he just strangles her to death. him killing shae is basically the act that starts him down the path of villainy.
She literally sold him out for promises by Cersei and then tried to seduce his father while he rotted in the black cells.
Literally well deserved
keep in mind shae was like 16, and tyrion brought her to king's landing expressly against his father's orders and put her in danger of being found out and killed just because he wanted to bang her. not saying shae wasn't a c**t, but she was brought into a situation way over her head by tyrion himself. and there's no reason to doubt that cersei and/or tywin didn't threaten her if she didn't comply.
yeah she's always asking tyrion about getting to keep israeliteels and nice clothes and doesn't like having to dress like a serving girl to keep her identity hidden. tyrion is also aware that she doesn't actually love him but doesn't care because the LARP is the only thing he has.
GRRM is a cumbrain neckbeard edgelord. The homosexual wears a fricking fedora. I have no idea how he blew up so big, all he writes is smut and gore and got so full of himself thinking he was comparable to tolkien.
Martin never wrote Jane dying at the red wedding. She wasn't even there in the books. D&D changed the dynamic of almost every relationship from the novels and wrote in a bunch of rape and coercion out of nowhere. Maybe the only ones they didn't ruin were Ned/Cat and Viserys/Dany .
not as much as assassinations in history. one dude had metal pipe pushed in his ass and his murderers stick red hot rod through it so there were no signs of assassination outside
They weren't competent enough writers to pull off the book Red Wedding, with a dozen familiar characters dying at once; so they replaced it with moronic love plotline and le baby stab.
An early case/warning of what became the norm later in the show: D&D feeling the need to "add their touch" to the story instead of just adapting Martin's work cause the thought they knew better. Also some proto-SJW shit years before it became the norm: she's a flawless empowered woman who left her life of privilege to become a sassy nurse who talks back to kings and "speaks her mind", instead of a normal feudal Westerosi lady like in the book, where she barely appears (which makes her presence in the show even more annoying; they sacrificed screentime that could have been devoted to showing more book stuff to include her).
Ultimately they fricked up by not embracing the "Talisa is a lannister spy" story. Film the book red wedding and reveal she was involved, shocking show and book readers at the same time.
>Because nobody would believe Robb married Jeyne only because he deflowered her.
If people can believe Ned being so autistic about honor that he willingly marches to his doom, I think they would buy Robb being a decent dude. It's the culture of the setting.
The exact reason was probably so they could add in your pic related.
Having Robb's wife get shanked to death in her pregnant belly ups the shock factor as well as the tragedy while also conveniently getting them out of having to adapt the already convoluted Sybil Spicer's conspiracy plotline from the books.
Making Jeyne Volantene was also an actually fairly smart way to introduce Volantis in general and potentially simplify their involvement in Dany and Aegon's Second Dance of Dragons. If the Lannister/ Baratheon regime assassinated the daughter of a high ranking noble or even a Triarch, it would make them more willing to side with whoever overthrew them (i.e. Aegon, who they will most likely side with in the books since Dany took a huge dump on the slave trade). They even have Talisa give a monologue about growing up in Volantis that is centered around the slave trade, which could be used to lead into the slave revolt which will likely happen in the books as well.
Unfortunately Bravo D&D scrapped that plotline/ FACTION of the story entirely throwing one in a line of many other good adaptational decisions they made into the dumpster because they are moronic, overconfident, and lazy.
Same reason they made Shae a greasy 30-something empowered sex worker who loves a midget.
Shae literally is a hooker who sleeps with Tyrion and is sassy tho
it's implied she actually loves him in the show though. in the books it's pretty clear she's just a gold digging prostitute.
I also recall Tyrion being a lot more of an butthole in the books. If I recall correctly he just straight up kills her, in the show they change it to her attacking him first.
She literally sold him out for promises by Cersei and then tried to seduce his father while he rotted in the black cells.
Literally well deserved
That's not really the point, just that they changed it to her attacking him first. Can't have show Tyrion kill a woman unless it's in self defense.
She went for a knife. She chose her side.
>then tried to seduce his father while he rotted in the black cells.
Shae was fricking Tywin well before that
yep. in the book she calls him "my giant" which was something she said in court that everyone laughed at, and this triggers the frick out of him so he just strangles her to death. him killing shae is basically the act that starts him down the path of villainy.
keep in mind shae was like 16, and tyrion brought her to king's landing expressly against his father's orders and put her in danger of being found out and killed just because he wanted to bang her. not saying shae wasn't a c**t, but she was brought into a situation way over her head by tyrion himself. and there's no reason to doubt that cersei and/or tywin didn't threaten her if she didn't comply.
>in the books it's pretty clear she's just a gold digging prostitute.
Really? Interesting.
yeah she's always asking tyrion about getting to keep israeliteels and nice clothes and doesn't like having to dress like a serving girl to keep her identity hidden. tyrion is also aware that she doesn't actually love him but doesn't care because the LARP is the only thing he has.
A horse that good doesn't jump have to haver
This kill was fricked up
GRRM is a cumbrain neckbeard edgelord. The homosexual wears a fricking fedora. I have no idea how he blew up so big, all he writes is smut and gore and got so full of himself thinking he was comparable to tolkien.
Martin never wrote Jane dying at the red wedding. She wasn't even there in the books. D&D changed the dynamic of almost every relationship from the novels and wrote in a bunch of rape and coercion out of nowhere. Maybe the only ones they didn't ruin were Ned/Cat and Viserys/Dany .
not as much as assassinations in history. one dude had metal pipe pushed in his ass and his murderers stick red hot rod through it so there were no signs of assassination outside
They wanted a poc
It's because DnD have a thing for brown women
They weren't competent enough writers to pull off the book Red Wedding, with a dozen familiar characters dying at once; so they replaced it with moronic love plotline and le baby stab.
Her actress is Charlie Chaplins granddaughter. She is one of them.
If only you knew how Bad things really are
Rlly? Wot
An early case/warning of what became the norm later in the show: D&D feeling the need to "add their touch" to the story instead of just adapting Martin's work cause the thought they knew better. Also some proto-SJW shit years before it became the norm: she's a flawless empowered woman who left her life of privilege to become a sassy nurse who talks back to kings and "speaks her mind", instead of a normal feudal Westerosi lady like in the book, where she barely appears (which makes her presence in the show even more annoying; they sacrificed screentime that could have been devoted to showing more book stuff to include her).
Ultimately they fricked up by not embracing the "Talisa is a lannister spy" story. Film the book red wedding and reveal she was involved, shocking show and book readers at the same time.
>Why did this they have this fanfiction character instead of Jeyne Westerling?
Because nobody would believe Robb married Jeyne only because he deflowered her.
>Because nobody would believe Robb married Jeyne only because he deflowered her.
If people can believe Ned being so autistic about honor that he willingly marches to his doom, I think they would buy Robb being a decent dude. It's the culture of the setting.
Jews.
When did you realize that D&D were hacks from the very beginning? They just had better material back then, which compensated for their incompetence.
when they butchered ACOK with the stannis vs renly scene
The exact reason was probably so they could add in your pic related.
Having Robb's wife get shanked to death in her pregnant belly ups the shock factor as well as the tragedy while also conveniently getting them out of having to adapt the already convoluted Sybil Spicer's conspiracy plotline from the books.
Making Jeyne Volantene was also an actually fairly smart way to introduce Volantis in general and potentially simplify their involvement in Dany and Aegon's Second Dance of Dragons. If the Lannister/ Baratheon regime assassinated the daughter of a high ranking noble or even a Triarch, it would make them more willing to side with whoever overthrew them (i.e. Aegon, who they will most likely side with in the books since Dany took a huge dump on the slave trade). They even have Talisa give a monologue about growing up in Volantis that is centered around the slave trade, which could be used to lead into the slave revolt which will likely happen in the books as well.
Unfortunately Bravo D&D scrapped that plotline/ FACTION of the story entirely throwing one in a line of many other good adaptational decisions they made into the dumpster because they are moronic, overconfident, and lazy.
Bump
I like how GoT threads now need an emergency bump 20 posts in
fricking trash show